Ahmić and Others v. Bosnia and Herzegovina
Struck out of the list
Berörda konventionsartiklar
FOURTH SECTION
Application no. 28230/18 Mirsada AHMIĆ against Bosnia and Herzegovina and 42 other applications
(see appended table)
The European Court of Human Rights (Fourth Section), sitting on 19 November 2020 as a Committee composed of:
Armen Harutyunyan, President, Jolien Schukking, Ana Maria Guerra Martins, judges,
and Liv Tigerstedt, Acting Deputy Section Registrar,
Having regard to the above applications lodged on the various dates indicated in the appended table,
Having deliberated, decides as follows:
FACTS AND PROCEDURE
The list of applicants is set out in the appended table.
The applicants were represented by Ms H. Kapetan, a lawyer practising in Travnik.
The applicants’ complaints under Article 6 § 1 of the Convention and Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 concerning the non-enforcement of domestic decisions against the Central Bosnia Canton were communicated to the Government of Bosnia and Herzegovina (“the Government”).
THE LAW
Having regard to the similar subject matter of the applications, the Court finds it appropriate to examine them jointly in a single decision.
The Court has recently examined the leading case concerning the non-enforcement of domestic decisions against the Central Bosnia Canton (see Akeljić and Others v. Bosnia and Herzegovina (dec.), nos. 8039/19 and 24 others, 5 November 2020). Having noted that the Central Bosnia Canton had adopted an action plan, undertaking to enforce all decisions against it, in chronological order, by 2032, the Court found that the matter had been resolved. There is no reason to decide otherwise in the present case.
In view of the above and turning to the present applications listed in the appended table, the Court considers that the matter has been resolved within the meaning of Article 37 § 1 (b) of the Convention and that respect for human rights as defined in the Convention and the Protocols thereto does not require it to continue the examination of the applications under Article 37 § 1 in fine .
Accordingly, the applications should be struck out of the list.
For these reasons, the Court, unanimously,
Decides to join the applications;
Decides to strike the applications out of its list of cases.
Done in English and notified in writing on 10 December 2020.
Liv Tigerstedt Armen Harutyunyan Acting Deputy Registrar President
APPENDIX
List of applications raising complaints under Article 6 § 1 of the Convention and Article 1 of Protocol No. 1
(non-enforcement or delayed enforcement of domestic decisions)
No.
Application no.
Date of introduction
Applicant’s name
Year of birth/Year of registration
Relevant domestic decision
28230/18
31/05/2018
Mirsada AHMIĆ
1957
Municipal Court in Travnik,
02/12/2013
28233/18
31/05/2018
Slavica BADROV
1960
Municipal Court in Travnik,
02/12/2013
28236/18
31/05/2018
Jasmina ŠABIĆ
1962
Municipal Court in Travnik,
02/12/2013
28239/18
31/05/2018
Zorica BARIŠIĆ
1970
Municipal Court in Travnik,
02/12/2013
28248/18
31/05/2015
Slavica VAVRA
1965
Municipal Court in Travnik,
02/12/2013
29218/18
04/06/2018
Marko JOZIĆ
1968
Municipal Court in Travnik,
05/06/2009
Municipal Court in Travnik,
02/09/2011
Municipal Court in Travnik,
31/01/2013
29225/18
04/06/2018
Haris KARADŽA
1969
Municipal Court in Travnik,
06/03/2009
Municipal Court in Travnik,
22/06/2010
Municipal Court in Travnik,
13/12/2013
29227/18
04/06/2018
Danijela JURINA
1984
Municipal Court in Travnik,
02/09/2011
Municipal Court in Travnik,
31/01/2013
29228/18
04/06/2018
Milenko MIKULIĆ
1970
Municipal Court in Travnik,
05/03/2009
29231/18
04/06/2018
Pava BATINIĆ
1960
Municipal Court in Travnik,
12/03/2009
30082/18
04/06/2018
Toni ŠARIĆ
1972
Municipal Court in Travnik,
02/09/2011
Municipal Court in Travnik,
31/01/2013
30085/18
04/06/2018
Ratko ŠARIĆ
1975
Municipal Court in Travnik,
05/03/2009
Municipal Court in Travnik,
04/01/2011
30089/18
04/06/2018
Husein ČAUŠEVIĆ
1966
Municipal Court in Travnik,
05/06/2009
30092/18
04/06/2018
Mehmed MUJIĆ
1967
Municipal Court in Travnik,
30/04/2010
30096/18
04/06/2018
Adriana BUDIMIR
1981
Municipal Court in Travnik,
05/06/2009
30102/18
04/06/2018
Senad VELAGIĆ
1971
Municipal Court in Travnik,
05/03/2009
Municipal Court in Travnik,
30/04/2010
47927/18
28/09/2018
Daša ERCEG PONJEVIĆ
1979
Municipal Court in Travnik,
06/03/2009
Municipal Court in Travnik,
10/06/2010
Municipal Court in Travnik,
27/02/2012
49411/18
12/10/2018
Halil HODŽIĆ
1975
Municipal Court in Travnik,
06/03/2009
Municipal Court in Travnik,
10/06/2010
Municipal Court in Travnik,
26/10/2011
Municipal Court in Travnik,
24/02/2013
49417/18
12/10/2018
Midhet HALAK
1968
Municipal Court in Travnik,
06/03/2009
Municipal Court in Travnik,
10/06/2010
Municipal Court in Travnik,
26/10/2011
Municipal Court in Travnik,
24/02/2013
49421/18
12/10/2018
Sabahudin BALTIĆ
1965
Municipal Court in Travnik,
06/03/2009
Municipal Court in Travnik,
09/06/2010
Municipal Court in Travnik,
27/02/2012
Municipal Court in Travnik,
22/04/2014
49423/18
12/10/2018
Zoran MATOŠEVIĆ
1965
Municipal Court in Travnik,
06/03/2009
Municipal Court in Travnik,
09/06/2010
Municipal Court in Travnik,
28/09/2011
Municipal Court in Travnik,
24/02/2013
49425/18
12/10/2018
Nihad KADRIĆ
1963
Municipal Court in Travnik,
06/03/2009
Municipal Court in Travnik,
10/06/2010
Municipal Court in Travnik,
12/05/2010
Municipal Court in Travnik,
24/02/2013
49426/18
12/10/2018
Edin KOBAŠ
1973
Municipal Court in Travnik,
06/03/2009
Municipal Court in Travnik,
10/06/2010
Municipal Court in Travnik,
27/02/2012
49428/18
12/10/2018
Dragan NAKIĆ
1971
Municipal Court in Travnik,
06/03/2009
Municipal Court in Travnik,
09/06/2010
Municipal Court in Travnik,
12/05/2010
Municipal Court in Travnik,
24/02/2013
49432/18
12/10/2018
Željko VISKOVIĆ
1976
Municipal Court in Travnik,
06/03/2009
Municipal Court in Travnik,
04/02/2011
Municipal Court in Travnik,
28/09/2011
Municipal Court in Travnik,
24/02/2013
49433/18
12/10/2018
Mile PERIĆ
1964
Municipal Court in Travnik,
06/03/2009
Municipal Court in Travnik,
09/06/2010
Municipal Court in Travnik,
28/09/2011
Municipal Court in Travnik,
24/02/2013
49440/18
12/10/2018
Amra ČAMPARA-LOLIĆ
1961
Municipal Court in Travnik,
30/09/2009
49442/18
12/10/2018
Ferid MEHIĆ
1968
Municipal Court in Travnik,
06/03/2009
Municipal Court in Travnik,
09/06/2010
Municipal Court in Travnik,
27/02/2012
Municipal Court in Travnik,
22/04/2014
50408/18
28/09/2018
AGROKOP D.O.O. U LIKVIDACIJI
1995
Municipal Court in Travnik,
20/05/2013
52704/18
16/10/2018
Josip ČEKO
1969
Municipal Court in Travnik,
06/03/2009
Municipal Court in Travnik,
09/06/2010
Municipal Court in Travnik,
27/02/2012
52706/18
16/10/2018
Svjetlana DINJAŠKI
1980
Municipal Court in Travnik,
06/03/2009
Municipal Court in Travnik,
09/06/2010
Municipal Court in Travnik,
27/02/2012
52707/18
16/10/2018
Kazimir MIŠKOVIĆ
1968
Municipal Court in Travnik,
06/03/2009
Municipal Court in Travnik,
09/06/2010
Municipal Court in Travnik,
27/02/2012
Municipal Court in Travnik,
22/04/2014
52708/18
16/10/2018
Tugomir VRHOVAC
1964
Municipal Court in Travnik,
06/03/2009
Municipal Court in Travnik,
04/02/2011
Municipal Court in Travnik,
28/09/2011
Municipal Court in Travnik,
24/02/2013
52709/18
16/10/2018
Zerid SIJAH
1973
Municipal Court in Travnik,
06/03/2009
Municipal Court in Travnik,
09/06/2010
Municipal Court in Travnik,
28/09/2011
Municipal Court in Travnik,
24/02/2013
52711/18
16/10/2018
Darijo ŠIPIĆ
1975
Municipal Court in Travnik,
06/03/2009
Municipal Court in Travnik,
04/02/2011
Municipal Court in Travnik,
27/02/2012
Municipal Court in Travnik,
22/04/2014
52712/18
16/10/2018
Sanja LAZIĆ
1964
Municipal Court in Travnik,
06/03/2009
Municipal Court in Travnik,
10/06/2010
Municipal Court in Travnik,
26/10/2011
Municipal Court in Travnik,
24/02/2013
54093/18
16/10/2018
Semir BEGOVIĆ
1964
Municipal Court in Travnik,
06/03/2009
Municipal Court in Travnik,
09/06/2010
Municipal Court in Travnik,
27/02/2012
Municipal Court in Travnik,
22/04/2014
54128/18
16/10/2018
Dragan ĐIDO
1972
Municipal Court in Travnik,
06/03/2009
Municipal Court in Travnik,
09/06/2010
Municipal Court in Travnik,
27/02/2012
54134/18
16/10/2018
Boro ZEC
1969
Municipal Court in Travnik,
06/03/2009
Municipal Court in Travnik,
04/02/2011
Municipal Court in Travnik,
12/05/2010
Municipal Court in Travnik,
24/02/2013
59110/18
15/11/2018
Vinko MATOŠEVIĆ
1960
Municipal Court in Travnik,
06/03/2009
Municipal Court in Travnik,
09/06/2010
Municipal Court in Travnik,
28/09/2011
6921/19
18/01/2019
Drago MILINOVIĆ
1970
Municipal Court in Travnik,
05/03/2009
Municipal Court in Travnik,
24/10/2014
31091/19
29/05/2019
Jelka VASIĆ
1963
Municipal Court in Travnik,
20/01/2014
Municipal Court in Travnik,
29/01/2016
56335/19
13/10/2019
Mustafa TIHAK
1979
Municipal Court in Travnik,
05/06/2009