lagen.nu
no. 42789/23

Supreme Religious Administration of Muslims of All Georgia v. Georgia

Inadmissible

Domstol
European Court of Human Rights
Avgörandedatum
2026-10-06
ECLI
ECLI:CE:ECHR:2026:1006DEC004278923
Artiklar
P12-1, 35
Källa
hudoc.echr.coe.int

Berörda konventionsartiklar

FOURTH SECTION

Application no. 42789/23 SUPREME RELIGIOUS ADMINISTRATION OF MUSLIMS OF ALL GEORGIA against Georgia

The European Court of Human Rights (Fourth Section), sitting on 6 October 2026 as a Chamber composed of:

Lorraine Schembri Orland , President , Lado Chanturia, Faris Vehabović, Anja Seibert-Fohr, Sebastian Răduleţu, András Jakab, Corinna Wissels , judges , and Hasan Bakırcı, Section Registrar,

Having regard to the above application lodged on 30 November 2023,

Having regard to the observations submitted by the respondent Government and the observations in reply submitted by the applicant organisation,

Having deliberated, decides as follows:

Introduction

1 The case concerns the allocation of municipal funding to religious organisations at the local level. The applicant organisation complained under Article 1 of Protocol No. 12 to the Convention that it had been discriminated against on grounds of religion.

THE FACTS

2 The applicant organisation, the Supreme Religious Administration of Muslims of All Georgia, was established under Georgian law on 13 June 2013, with its head office located in Marneuli, Georgia. It was represented before the Court by Ms T. Mikeladze, a lawyer practising in Tbilisi.

3 The Georgian Government (“the Government”) were represented by their Agent, Mr Beka Dzamashvili, First Deputy Minister of Justice.

4 The facts of the case, as submitted by the parties, may be summarised as follows.

5 The applicant organisation is a legal entity of public law established under the relevant domestic legislation governing public organisations pursuing public and community interests. It is financed through State funding and private donations and serves as an independent religious centre representing Shia Muslims in Georgia, with particular emphasis on the Twelver Shia branch. According to its articles of incorporation, the applicant organisation is the central governing body of Shia Muslim religious life in Georgia. It oversees Shia Islamic religious institutions, including mosques, madrasas and educational centres, as well as the clergy and the provision of religious services. Its principal objectives include promoting Shia Islam in Georgia, protecting and representing the interests of the Shia Muslim community, and developing religious education and training members of the clergy, including imams.

6 . On 17 October 2019 and again on 20 October 2020 the Marneuli and Hujabi Diocese (“the Marneuli and Hujabi Diocese”), a regional division of the Apostolic Autocephalous Orthodox Church of Georgia (“the Georgian Church”), applied to the Marneuli City Council for municipal funding of approximately 400,000 Georgian laris (GEL – approximately 118,340 euros (EUR) at the material time). The Diocese stated that the funds were being sought to cover expenses relating to the preservation and maintenance of historical sites.

7 . On 1 December 2021 the Marneuli City Council adopted Resolution no. 41 approving the municipality’s budget for 2022. The total budget amounted to approximately GEL 36,409,800 (approximately EUR 10,772,000) and covered, among other areas, sport, education, youth, science, research, culture and religious activities. For the purposes of the present case, the budget contained two relevant allocations entitled “b.b. – cultural life activities” and “b.g. – religious and similar public activities”.

8 The cultural life activities budget line aimed to finance cultural events within the municipality. It primarily covered the celebrations of Nowruz Bayram, the Persian New Year and the spring festival observed by Georgia’s Azerbaijani-speaking population, as well as the local wine festival “Marneuli – Cradle of Wine”. A total of GEL 145,000 (approximately EUR 42,900) was allocated for those activities.

9 . The religious and similar public activities budget line stated that its objective was “to promote religious tolerance and enhance the spiritual life of the local population through financial support for monasteries, churches and mosques within the municipality”. Under that budget line, GEL 400,000 (approximately EUR 118,340) was allocated to the Diocese, while a further GEL 10,000 (approximately EUR 2,960) was earmarked for the communal expenses of all religious organisations, including mosques.

10 The allocation to the Marneuli and Hujabi Diocese was to be paid in four quarterly instalments of GEL 100,000. The allocation for communal expenses was to be distributed among all churches, monasteries and mosques in accordance with fixed maximum amounts: up to GEL 300 (approximately EUR 80) for each place of worship in the town of Marneuli; up to GEL 100 (approximately EUR 30) for those situated in rural areas without natural gas; and up to GEL 50 (approximately EUR 15) for those located in rural areas supplied with natural gas.

11 On 18 February 2022, when implementing the budgetary allocation, the Marneuli municipality signed a separate contract with the Marneuli and Hujabi Diocese under the domestic rules of contract law. The contract provided an additional legal basis for the transfer of the funds and specified that they were intended “to support the Diocese’s proper functioning and the purpose of preservation and maintenance of religious sites with cultural heritage status”.

12 In February 2022 the applicant organisation brought proceedings before the Bolnisi District Court. It sought, inter alia , a declaration that the allocation of funds from the 2022 budget of the Marneuli municipality exclusively to the Marneuli and Hujabi Diocese constituted discrimination on grounds of religion. It further requested that, should such discrimination be established, both the municipal resolution authorising the allocation and the contract implementing it be declared null and void (that is, set aside with retrospective effect).

13 . The applicant organisation argued that allocating municipal funds exclusively to the Georgian Church in a municipality where the majority of the population was Shia Muslim (see paragraph 17 below) lacked any objective and reasonable justification. It further submitted that similar patterns of disproportionate funding in favour of the Marneuli and Hujabi Diocese had existed in previous years and that placing the Georgian Church in such a privileged position was incompatible with the principles of secularism and domestic anti-discrimination law.

14 . The respondent municipality disputed those arguments. It maintained that the disputed allocation had not been intended to promote religion. Rather, its purpose had been to finance the restoration and maintenance of cultural heritage monuments within the municipality, including religious buildings. The municipality pointed out that there were approximately 79 churches and monasteries in its territory, of which 55 had the status of cultural heritage monuments and were administered by the Marneuli and Hujabi Diocese. In those circumstances, it argued that allocating the disputed funds to the Diocese for the repair and maintenance of those sites had been both necessary and justified.

15 By a judgment of 1 July 2022, the Bolnisi District Court allowed the applicant organisation’s claim. It held that the allocation in the 2022 municipal budget of GEL 400,000 exclusively to the Marneuli and Hujabi Diocese had amounted to discrimination on grounds of religion.

16 . In reaching that conclusion, the court first examined the religious composition of the population. Referring to the 2014 national census, it noted that 83.4% of Georgia’s population identified as Christian, 10.4% as Muslim (Shia and Sunni), 2.9% as members of the Armenian Apostolic Church and 3% as belonging to other religious denominations.

17 . The court further observed that the Marneuli municipality differed significantly from the national picture. Of its population of 104,300, 83.2% were Muslims, 9.3% were Christians and 7.5% belonged to other religious denominations.

18 . Addressing the respondent authority’s argument concerning the number of historical Christian religious sites (see paragraph 14 above), the court found that the Marneuli municipality contained 37 mosques, only two of which had been designated as cultural heritage monuments.

19 The court also held that the special role accorded to the Georgian Church under the Constitutional Agreement (see paragraph 44 below) could not be interpreted as conferring an unconditional privileged status. Rather, that recognition had to be interpreted consistently with the State’s international obligations, including its obligations under anti-discrimination law.

20 . The court then considered whether the applicant organisation and the Marneuli and Hujabi Diocese were in a comparable situation. It found that both organisations pursued similar objectives, namely promoting and supporting the religious activities of their respective denominations in Georgia. It therefore concluded that they were comparable in terms of the nature and purpose of their organisational missions.

21 The court next examined whether domestic law entitled religious organisations to receive funding from municipal budgets. It distinguished between two possible legal bases for such funding, reflected in the contract underlying the disputed budgetary allocation: to support religious activities; and (ii) to cover the restoration and maintenance of cultural heritage sites.

22 . As regards funding for the restoration and maintenance of cultural heritage sites, the court found that such a right existed under section 56(b) of the Cultural Heritage Act, which required local authorities to finance those costs (see paragraph 48 below). However, pursuant to section 28(1) of the same Act, the funding was payable only to the owners or recognised administrators of the relevant cultural heritage sites. The applicant organisation did not satisfy that requirement. Public Land Registry records showed that it neither owned nor administered any religious buildings in the Marneuli municipality designated as cultural heritage monuments, including the two protected mosques referred to above, nor had it produced any evidence of contributing to their maintenance.

23 By contrast, under Article 7 § 1 and Article 9 § 1 of the Constitutional Agreement, the Marneuli and Hujabi Diocese formed part of the Georgian Church, which was recognised as the ultimate owner of all Christian religious sites, including those designated as cultural heritage monuments. The Diocese was also responsible for managing, repairing and maintaining the religious infrastructure within its territory. The court therefore concluded that, in relation to funding for the restoration and maintenance of cultural heritage sites, the applicant organisation and the Diocese were not in a comparable situation and that no claim of discriminatory treatment could arise on that basis.

24 . Turning to funding for the proper functioning of religious institutions, the court found, after examining the relevant domestic legislation, including Government Decree no. 117 of 27 January 2014, that domestic law did not confer on religious organisations any right to receive such funding from municipal budgets (see paragraphs 49-52 below). The decree only recognised the State’s obligation to finance religious organisations through the central State budget.

25 Nevertheless, the court held that the absence of legal entitlement did not preclude a claim of discrimination. Relying on the constitutional principle of equality, it held that once a municipality decided to allocate public funds to a religious organisation, it was required to do so without discrimination. Since the applicant organisation and the Marneuli and Hujabi Diocese were, generally speaking, in a comparable situation given that both functioned to support the religion of their respective denomination (see paragraph 20 above), the decision to only fund the Diocese constituted differential treatment falling within the scope of Article 11 of the Constitution.

26 The court further found that the respondent municipality had failed to provide an objective and reasonable justification for that differential treatment. In particular, the decision to only fund the Marneuli and Hujabi Diocese, while excluding the applicant organisation, had lacked sufficient justification. Nor could the difference in treatment be justified solely by the special role of the Georgian Church recognised under Article 8 of the Constitution.

27 Emphasising the principle of State neutrality, the court stated that “any action of the State must pursue a secular purpose, must not favour any particular religion, and must not create the impression of excessive affiliation with a specific religion”. It further observed that, despite bearing the burden of proof in anti-discrimination proceedings, the respondent municipality had failed to demonstrate that the preferential treatment had resulted from objective historical considerations rather than constituting an end in itself.

28 Having found that the allocation of GEL 400,000 to the Marneuli and Hujabi Diocese in the 2022 municipal budget had been discriminatory, the Bolnisi District Court set aside, with prospective effect ( ex nunc ), the municipal resolution forming the legal basis for that allocation. It declined, however, to declare the resolution null and void with retrospective effect ( ex tunc ), as requested by the applicant organisation.

29 . On 22 August 2022 the Marneuli municipality appealed against the judgment of 1 July 2022, relying essentially on the arguments advanced before the first-instance court (see paragraph 13 above). It submitted, in particular, that the lower court had erred in treating the two purposes identified in the implementing contract – support for the religious activities of the Marneuli and Hujabi Diocese and support for the maintenance and restoration of cultural heritage sites – as separate objectives. According to the municipality, the latter purpose merely clarified and gave practical effect to the former. Properly understood, the disputed budgetary allocation pursued a single objective, namely the maintenance and preservation of religious buildings holding cultural heritage status.

30 . The municipality further argued that that interpretation reflected the applicable domestic law. While municipal authorities could finance the restoration and maintenance of cultural heritage sites, only the central State authorities, through the State Agency for Religious Affairs, were empowered to provide financial support to religious organisations as such. Since the Marneuli and Hujabi Diocese was responsible under domestic law for maintaining 55 religious sites with cultural heritage status, the disputed allocation simply enabled the municipality to fulfil its statutory obligations in that regard.

31 The applicant organisation replied that the first-instance judgment was correct for the reasons stated therein and should be upheld.

32 By a judgment of 8 December 2022, the Tbilisi Court of Appeal allowed the municipality’s appeal in part, amended the first-instance judgment and dismissed the applicant organisation’s discrimination claim as ill-founded.

33 . The Tbilisi Court of Appeal explicitly endorsed the lower court’s findings of fact (see paragraphs 16-18 and 22 above) and agreed with the remainder of its legal analysis, except on one decisive point. In its view, the budgetary allocation did not pursue two separate objectives. Having examined the relevant domestic legislation, the Court of Appeal held that the municipality lacked the authority to finance the activities of religious organisations as such. Its remit only extended to supporting the restoration and maintenance of cultural heritage sites, including religious buildings managed by the relevant religious organisations. It therefore concluded that the disputed allocation pursued a single purpose: enabling the Marneuli municipality to discharge its statutory obligation to support the restoration and maintenance of religious sites holding cultural heritage status. The Court of Appeal also noted that supervision of actual expenditure, ordinarily undertaken through public auditing of municipal budgets, had not formed part of the applicant’s claim and therefore fell outside the proceedings.

34 . The Court of Appeal further observed that the Marneuli municipality contained 55 historic churches and monasteries, compared with only two mosques enjoying cultural heritage status, neither of which was owned or managed by the applicant organisation. It therefore found nothing discriminatory in the municipality’s decision to allocate funding to the Marneuli and Hujabi Diocese, which was responsible for managing those cultural heritage sites.

35 . The Court of Appeal also agreed with the lower court that the applicant organisation and the Marneuli and Hujabi Diocese were not in a comparable situation as regards the maintenance and restoration of cultural heritage sites. It added that, unlike the Diocese (see paragraph 6 above), the applicant organisation had never requested municipal funding for that specific purpose.

36 Lastly, the Court of Appeal observed that there was nothing in the case file to suggest, nor had the applicant organisation alleged, that Muslim religious organisations in Georgia had been subjected to State persecution or prevented from carrying out their religious activities.

37 . On 7 February 2023 the applicant organisation lodged an appeal on points of law with the Supreme Court of Georgia against the judgment of 8 December 2022. It argued, in substance, that the Court of Appeal had erred in concluding that the disputed budgetary allocation had solely served to finance the restoration and maintenance of cultural heritage sites. According to the applicant organisation, as the first-instance court had correctly found, the allocation had pursued two distinct objectives, namely supporting both the proper functioning of the Marneuli and Hujabi Diocese and the maintenance of cultural heritage sites. By funding the proper functioning of the Diocese, the municipality had placed it in a more favourable position than the applicant organisation. The applicant organisation further maintained that the allocation had in reality been intended primarily to support the Diocese’s religious activities rather than the preservation of cultural heritage sites. In that connection, it referred to another budgetary provision of the municipality’s 2022 budget entitled “cultural life activities”, which, in its view, already covered cultural activities. It therefore argued that, if the purpose of the disputed allocation had indeed been to promote religious tolerance and enhance the spiritual life of the population, allocating the entirety of the funds to the Marneuli and Hujabi Diocese in a municipality where the majority of the population was Muslim had amounted to unjustified discrimination on grounds of religion.

38 . On 7 June 2023 the Administrative Chamber of the Supreme Court declared the appeal on points of law inadmissible. In doing so, it fully endorsed the reasoning of the Court of Appeal, including its conclusion that the disputed allocation had been justified by the municipality’s obligation to contribute to the protection of cultural heritage. After analysing the case file in the light of the applicable legislation, the Supreme Court held that, in their relations with religious organisations, municipal authorities were only authorised to fund, together with the central authorities, the preservation and maintenance of cultural heritage sites, which in Georgia frequently coincided with places of worship, such as churches, monasteries, mosques and synagogues. By contrast, the financing of religious organisations of the various denominations for the purpose of supporting religious activities as such fell exclusively within the competence of the central State authorities.

39 The Supreme Court accordingly dismissed the applicant organisation’s argument that the municipality had allocated local budgetary funds in order to support the Georgian Church, represented locally by the Marneuli and Hujabi Diocese. It held that the only lawful purpose of the allocation had been to enable the municipality to fulfil its statutory obligation to contribute to the preservation of cultural heritage sites within its territory. In that connection, it observed that the Marneuli municipality contained 55 churches and monasteries, but only two mosques, holding cultural heritage status. It therefore considered it legitimate for the municipality to have allocated the disputed funds to the Marneuli and Hujabi Diocese, which was responsible for maintaining those 55 churches and monasteries.

40 . As regards the two mosques with cultural heritage status, the Supreme Court reiterated that the applicant organisation neither owned nor was legally responsible for maintaining them. It therefore concluded that the applicant organisation could not contend that it had been subjected to discriminatory treatment merely because the municipality had funded the Marneuli and Hujabi Diocese for the maintenance and preservation of cultural heritage sites.

41 The Supreme Court also addressed the question of State funding for Muslim organisations from the central State budget. Referring to the annual public reports of the State Agency for Religious Affairs, the authority responsible for financing major religious denominations from the central budget, it noted that between 2015 and 2022 the Muslim communities of Georgia, both Shia and Sunni, represented by various legal entities including the applicant organisation, had received a total of GEL 30,570,000 (approximately EUR 9,045,000) in State grants and subsidies. According to the same reports, the applicant organisation itself received GEL 5,500,000 (approximately EUR 1,627,218) in total in 2020 and 2021 – GEL 2,750,000 (approximately EUR 813,609) per year – while the figures for the distribution of funds for 2022 had not yet been finalised.

42 The Supreme Court accordingly concluded that the appeal on points of law was ill-founded. Its decision of 7 June 2023 was served on the applicant organisation on 31 July 2023.

RELEVANT DOMESTIC FRAMEWORK AND PRACTICE

43 The relevant constitutional provisions read, at the material time, as follows:

Article 7 § 4

“Citizens of Georgia shall regulate matters of local importance through local self-government, in accordance with the legislation of Georgia. The separation of powers between State authorities and self-governing units shall be based on the principle of subsidiarity. The State shall ensure that the financial resources of a self-governing unit correspond to the powers of the self-governing unit as determined by organic law”

Article 8

“Freedom of belief and religion shall be guaranteed. At the same time, the State shall recognise the special role of the Apostolic Autocephalous Orthodox Church of Georgia in the history of Georgia and its independence from the State. The relationship between the State of Georgia and the Apostolic Autocephalous Orthodox Church of Georgia shall be determined by a Constitutional Agreement, which shall be in full compliance with the universally recognised principles and norms of international law in the field of human rights and freedoms.”

Article 11 § 1

“Every person shall be equal before the law. Discrimination shall be prohibited on the grounds of race, colour, sex, origin, ethnic affiliation, language, religion, political or other opinions, social affiliation, property or titular status, place of residence or any other characteristic.”

Article 16

“1. Every person shall have freedom of belief, religion and conscience.

2 The restriction of these rights shall only be permissible in accordance with the law, where necessary in a democratic society for the protection of public safety, health or the rights of others.

3 No one shall be persecuted on the grounds of his or her beliefs, religion or conscience, or be coerced into expressing his or her views concerning them.”

Article 20 § 4

“Everyone has the right to care for the protection of cultural heritage. Cultural heritage shall be protected by law.”

Article 75

“1. The powers of State authorities and self-governing units shall be separated.

2 Self-governing units shall be authorised, in compliance with legislation, to decide on their own initiative any matter that is not assigned by law to the exclusive powers of State authorities or of one of the autonomous republics, and with respect to which decision-making is not excluded by law from the powers of self-governing units.

3 A self-governing unit shall exercise its own powers independently and under its own responsibility, within the framework of the legislation of Georgia. Its powers defined by organic law shall be full and exclusive.

4 The State authorities shall delegate powers to a self-governing unit on the basis of a legislative act or an agreement, together with the transfer of appropriate material and financial resources.

5 The State authorities shall exercise legal supervision over the activities of a self-governing unit. The supervision of a self-governing unit’s activities for the purpose of ensuring the expediency of decisions shall be permissible only with respect to decisions adopted on the basis of delegated powers. State supervision shall be carried out in accordance with the procedure established by organic law, in compliance with the principle of proportionality.”

44 . On 22 October 2002 the Parliament of Georgia ratified a Constitutional Agreement concluded on 14 October 2002 between the State of Georgia and the Georgian Church, pursuant to Article 8 of the Constitution. The relevant parts of the Constitutional Agreement provide as follows:

Article 7

“1. The State shall recognise as Church property Orthodox churches and monasteries (active and inactive), their ruins and the plots of land on which they are located, throughout the territory of Georgia.

2 Protection zones for the above structures, as well as rules for their maintenance and use, shall be determined by the relevant State authority in accordance with applicable legislation and in agreement with the Church.”

Article 8

“1. The State shall recognise as Church property ecclesiastical treasures kept under State protection (in museums and repositories), except for items in private ownership.

2 The above ecclesiastical treasures, as part of the national heritage, shall be under joint ownership of the State and the Church in accordance with applicable legislation (except for holy relics and sacred remains).”

Article 9

“1. The State and the Church shall jointly ensure proper protection and maintenance of ecclesiastical buildings and treasures of historical, cultural, archaeological and architectural value.

2 The State, in agreement with the Church and in accordance with applicable legislation, shall approve additional rules regarding the use of ecclesiastical treasures held in museums and repositories, as well as projects for restoration, conservation, or painting of churches of historical and cultural value.”

45 . The Code on Local Self-Government was adopted by the Parliament of Georgia on 19 February 2014. As indicated in Article 1, its purpose is to define the legal basis for the exercise of local self-government, the powers of local self-government bodies, the rules for their establishment and operation, their finances and property, their relations with citizens, central State authorities, and legal entities under public and private law, as well as the procedures for State supervision over the activities of local self-government bodies.

46 Pursuant to Article 16 §§ 1 and 2 (t), local self-government bodies (such as municipal councils) must spend municipal funds in accordance with domestic legislation and possess their “own” “full and exclusive powers” in matters relating to the preservation and maintenance of cultural heritage sites. These powers are exercised independently and without central State supervision.

47 According to Article 2 (k) of the General Administrative Code, the “discretionary power” of a public authority refers to “the authority of an administrative body or official to select the most appropriate decision from among several legally permissible options”. The requirement of “lawful administrative action” under Article 5, read together with the normative hierarchy established by Section 7 §§ 7 and 12(c) of the Organic Law on Normative Acts, prohibits a municipal budget resolution from overriding national legislation. Article 6 further requires discretionary powers to be exercised within statutory limits and for the purpose for which they were granted.

48 . The relevant provisions of the Act read, at the material time, as follows:

Section 4 – Cultural heritage protection authorities

“1. State protection of cultural heritage shall be exercised, within the scope of powers defined by the legislation of Georgia, by the Ministry of Culture of Georgia (hereinafter ‘the Ministry’); the Ministry of Justice of Georgia; municipal bodies, as well as other State authorities; legal entities under public law and legal entities under private law; and, within the territories of the Autonomous Republics of Abkhazia and Ajara, by the respective authorities of the Autonomous Republics of Abkhazia and Ajara.

2 In the field of cultural heritage protection, State and municipal bodies shall exercise their powers in accordance with the norms established by Articles 7, 8, and 9 of the Constitutional Agreement between the State of Georgia and the Apostolic Autocephalous Orthodox Church of Georgia.”

Section 7(1) – The municipality’s own [absolute and exclusive] powers in the field of cultural heritage protection

“2. Pursuant to subparagraph (t) of paragraph 2 of Article 16 of the Code on Local Self-Government, for the purpose of protecting cultural heritage, a municipality shall ensure the maintenance, conservation, reconstruction and restoration of cultural heritage monuments located within the territory of the municipality.”

Section 56 – Financing of cultural heritage protection

“1. Cultural heritage protection shall be financed:

(a) from the [central] State budget;

(b) from the budget of a municipality.”

49 . Pursuant to Decree no. 117 of 27 January 2014, the Georgian Government, acting through the executive branch, acknowledged that it had already assumed obligations vis-à-vis the Apostolic Autocephalous Orthodox Church of Georgia, the country’s dominant religion, and, with explicit reference to the constitutional principle of non-discrimination, undertook a similar responsibility to fund other major religious denominations present in the country, namely the Muslim, Jewish and Catholic communities and the Armenian Apostolic Church. The decree explained that the justification for that funding lay in the fact that, as acknowledged by the Georgian State, those religious denominations had suffered severe persecution during the Soviet period alongside the Georgian Church (Article 1 of the decree).

50 . The decree emphasised that all funding provided to those religious organisations was to be allocated strictly from the central State budget, paid annually, and that the determination of the exact amount of the relevant State subsidies and donations fell exclusively within the remit of the Georgian Government (Article 2 of the decree).

51 In cases where several religious organisations registered in the country represented the same religious denomination, the Georgian Government invited such organisations either to merge, to establish a single coordination council to receive the State funding for the denomination concerned or to provide the State with written notification designating a single religious organisation entitled to receive the State funds (Article 3 of the decree).

52 . Lastly, the decree stated that religious organisations representing the relevant denominations were free to use the funds received from the State budget for any religious activities deemed appropriate and permitted by law, including the performance of religious services, educational and publishing activities, the acquisition of property, the construction or repair of religious buildings, and any other activity permitted under Georgian legislation (Article 5 of the Decree).

THE LAW

53 . The applicant alleged that the respondent State had subjected it to discriminatory treatment on religious grounds owing to disparities in State funding at the municipal level of the Marneuli district, in violation of Article 1 of Protocol No. 12 to the Convention, which provides as follows:

“1. The enjoyment of any right set forth by law shall be secured without discrimination on any ground such as sex, race, colour, language, religion, political or other opinion, national or social origin, association with a national minority, property, birth or other status.

2 No one shall be discriminated against by any public authority on any ground such as those mentioned in paragraph 1.”

54 . The Government submitted at the outset that State funding of religious organisations did not constitute a right under domestic law that could be relied on by such organisations. Rather, the allocation of public funding fell within the discretionary powers of the relevant authorities, as understood under Article 2 (k) of the General Administrative Code. Under the relevant domestic legislation, financial support for the religious activities of religious organisations could only be granted by the central State authorities, acting through the State Agency for Religious Affairs and financed from the central State budget. Municipal authorities, by contrast, could only provide financial support within the limits of their own statutory powers, primarily by contributing to the preservation and maintenance of religious buildings designated as monuments of cultural heritage.

55 . The Government further observed that approximately 83.4% of Georgia’s population identified as Christian, whereas Muslims, both Shia and Sunni, accounted for approximately 10.73%. They also referred to the disparity in the number of religious sites. According to the Government, there were 1,914 active Christian churches and monasteries in Georgia (excluding those situated in the territories of Abkhazia and the South Ossetia region currently occupied by the Russian Federation), of which 640 had cultural heritage status. By contrast, there were 297 active mosques, only 24 of which enjoyed the same status.

56 . Alternatively, assuming that the applicant organisation and the Marneuli and Hujabi Diocese were in a relevantly similar situation and had been treated differently, the Government maintained that any difference in treatment had been objectively and reasonably justified. They argued that the disputed municipal allocation had not been intended to finance religious activities as such, which remained a matter for the central State authorities, but rather to support the preservation and maintenance of religious buildings designated as monuments of cultural heritage. In the Marneuli municipality, 55 churches and monasteries held that status, compared with only two mosques. The resulting difference in municipal funding for the maintenance of those sites had therefore been justified.

57 The Government further submitted that municipal funding for the preservation and maintenance of religious cultural heritage sites was allocated on the basis of need, following applications submitted by the relevant religious organisations. In the present case, the Marneuli and Hujabi Diocese had requested such funding (see paragraph 6 above), whereas the applicant organisation had never submitted a comparable application. It was therefore unjustified, in the Government’s view, to criticise the municipality for failing to grant funding that had never been requested. Had such an application been made, the municipality would have considered it in the exercise of its discretionary powers.

58 . Lastly, while maintaining that the present case only concerned the difference in municipal funding relating to the preservation and maintenance of cultural heritage sites, the Government also addressed the applicant organisation’s broader allegations concerning the treatment of Muslim organisations in Georgia. In that regard, the Government submitted that in 2024, the central State budget allocated GEL 25,000,000 (approximately EUR 7,397,000) to the Georgian Church and GEL 4,150,000 (approximately EUR 1,228,000) to Muslim organisations. In their opinion, those amounts could not be regarded as disproportionate when viewed in the light of the relative size of the Christian and Muslim populations or the respective numbers of churches and monasteries and active mosques (see paragraphs 14 and 16 and 55 above). The Government further noted that, in addition to financial support provided by the State Agency for Religious Affairs for the religious activities of the main religious denominations, the State also contributed to the preservation and maintenance of Muslim religious buildings. They added that every active mosque in Georgia was administered by an imam or akhund, usually assisted by one or more assistant imams, whose salaries were paid in full by the State.

59 In the light of the foregoing considerations taken as a whole, the Government submitted that the application was manifestly ill-founded and must be rejected as inadmissible under Article 35 §§ 3 and 4 of the Convention.

60 . The applicant organisation disputed the Government’s characterisation of the municipal allocation in issue as relating exclusively to the preservation of cultural heritage sites (see paragraph 56 above). It argued that both the relevant budgetary provision and the implementing contract demonstrated that the allocation had pursued two distinct objectives: supporting the proper functioning of the Marneuli and Hujabi Diocese and contributing to the maintenance of religious sites possessing cultural heritage status. According to the applicant organisation, the Government’s reliance on the second objective alone disregarded the broader purpose of the funding, namely promoting religious tolerance and the spiritual life of the local population. The applicant organisation further maintained that the maintenance of cultural heritage sites was already covered by a separate municipal budgetary programme (see paragraphs 7-9 above).

61 The applicant organisation further submitted that it and the Marneuli and Hujabi Diocese were in a relevantly similar situation. Both organisations performed comparable religious, cultural and social functions within the Marneuli municipality and therefore had an equivalent interest in obtaining municipal support for the benefit of their respective religious communities. In that connection, the applicant organisation argued that the Government’s reliance on the Georgian Church’s constitutional status, national demographic data and the greater number of churches and monasteries was misplaced. The relevant comparison had to be made at the municipal level, where approximately 83% of the population was Muslim and where local authorities were required to act in accordance with the principles of equality, neutrality and non-discrimination.

62 The applicant organisation further argued that, once the municipality decided to allocate public funds to religious organisations, it was obliged to exercise its discretionary powers in a non-discriminatory manner. It maintained that, although religious organisations had no right as such to receive State funding, any public funding that was granted had to be distributed on the basis of objective and reasonable criteria. It also disputed the Government’s contention that the absence of a request for funding precluded its complaint, arguing that the municipality remained under an obligation to ensure equal treatment between religious organisations in the exercise of its discretionary powers.

63 . Lastly, the applicant organisation maintained that the allocation in issue had lacked both a legitimate aim and an objective and reasonable justification. It argued that the domestic courts had failed to properly examine those issues, had disregarded the principles of State neutrality and equality, and had not scrutinised the absence of transparent criteria governing the allocation and use of the disputed funds. The applicant organisation also challenged the relevance of the Government’s reliance on State funding provided at the national level through the central budget and on other financial support granted to Muslim organisations, maintaining that the present case concerned discriminatory treatment in the exercise of municipal funding powers in Marneuli. Assuming that such central-level funding was relevant for the examination of the present case, the applicant organisation submitted additional information concerning the subsidies received by the Georgian Church from central State funding, asserting that those amounts had exceeded what the Muslim communities in Georgia had received.

64 At the outset, the Court considers it necessary to delimit the scope of the present case. In this connection, it notes that, having regard to the principle of subsidiarity, the scope of the case is determined by the subject matter of the domestic proceedings brought by the applicant organisation and complained of before the Court. In the present case, that scope is reflected in the applicant organisation’s discrimination claim, the respondent municipality’s defence and the reasoning of the domestic courts, as well as by the manner in which the complaint was formulated in the application and subsequently communicated to the respondent Government (see Radomilja and Others v. Croatia [GC], nos. 37685/10 and 22768/12, § 126, 20 March 2018, and also Greenpeace Nordic and Others v. Norway , no. 34068/21, § 282, 28 October 2025). Accordingly, the present case, as developed at the domestic level and presented to the Court, concerns exclusively the allocation of public funds from municipal budgets to religious organisations for the specific purposes prescribed by law (see paragraphs 6-24, 29-30, 34-35, 38 ‑ 40 and 53 above). This clarification is necessary because, in their observations before the Court, both parties have, to some extent, gone beyond that framework by advancing arguments concerning the funding of religious organisations from the central State budget (see paragraphs 58 and 63 above).

65 Furthermore, noting that one of the Government’s arguments may be understood as implicitly calling into question the applicability of Article 1 of Protocol No. 12 to the circumstances of the present case (see paragraph 54 above), the Court considers it necessary to address that issue. In this connection, it reiterates that Article 1 of Protocol No. 12 establishes a general prohibition of discrimination extending beyond the ambit of the rights and freedoms guaranteed by the Convention. According to the Explanatory Report to that Protocol, its scope encompasses not only the enjoyment of rights specifically granted under domestic law, but also the enjoyment of rights that may be inferred from clear obligations imposed on public authorities under domestic law, discrimination by public authorities in the exercise of their discretionary powers, and any other discriminatory act or omission attributable to a public authority. The Explanatory Report further explains that the two paragraphs of Article 1 of Protocol No. 12 are complementary, that their combined effect brings all those categories within the scope of the provision, and that the distinctions between the categories are not clear cut (see, as a recent authority, Stanković v. Bosnia and Herzegovina , no. 11103/23, §§ 21-23, 19 May 2026, with further references therein).

66 Turning to the present case, the Court observes that the relevant domestic legislation governing the financing of religious organisations by municipal authorities does not confer on such organisations a right to claim funding from municipal budgets (see paragraphs 45-48 above). Moreover, unlike the system of financial support provided by the central State authorities, where domestic law imposes specific obligations on the State in respect of certain religious organisations (see paragraphs 49-52 above), the allocation of funds by municipalities remains a matter of administrative discretion and is subject to further conditions prescribed by law (see paragraph 68 below). The allocation in question therefore concerns the exercise of discretionary public power, a category of cases expressly covered by Article 1 of Protocol No. 12, as explained in the Explanatory Report (see also Negovanović and Others v. Serbia , nos. 29907/16 and 3 others, §§ 52 ‑ 53, 25 January 2022).

67 The Court further reiterates that the meaning of the notion of “discrimination” in Article 1 of Protocol No. 12 is identical to that developed under Article 14 of the Convention. Accordingly, in applying the same term under Article 1 of Protocol No. 12, the Court therefore sees no reason to depart from its established case-law under Article 14. It must therefore examine whether the applicant organisation was in an analogous or relevantly similar situation to that of the comparator relied on, namely the Georgian Church. In this connection, the Court reiterates that the elements characterising different situations, and thus determining whether two persons or groups are in an analogous or relevantly similar situation, must be assessed in the light of the subject matter and purpose of the measure giving rise to the alleged difference in treatment. The assessment of comparability is therefore specific and contextual (see, for instance, Pinkas and Others v. Bosnia and Herzegovina , no. 8701/21, § 60, 4 October 2022, with further reference).

68 . In the present case, the Court observes that, under the relevant domestic legal framework, municipal authorities are empowered to provide financial support to religious organisations only in connection with the preservation and maintenance of places of worship which enjoy the status of protected cultural heritage sites. It is mindful of the applicant organisation’s argument that the wording of the relevant budgetary provision entitled “religious and similar public activities”, referring to the promotion of “religious tolerance and the spiritual life of the local population”, demonstrates that the allocation in issue pursued a broader objective than the preservation of cultural heritage (see paragraphs 9, 37 and 60 above). However, the Court notes that, in the present case, all three levels of jurisdiction, including the first-instance court which otherwise found in favour of the applicant organisation, consistently held that municipal funding of religious organisations could only lawfully be granted for the preservation and maintenance of religious sites enjoying cultural heritage status (see paragraphs 24, 33, 35 and 38 above). That interpretation is, moreover, supported by Government Decree no. 117, which makes it clear that financial support for the religious activities of religious organisations as such falls within the exclusive competence of the central State authorities and is to be financed from the central State budget (see paragraph 50 above). The Court further notes that the amount allocated to the Marneuli and Hujabi Diocese matched the sum it had requested from Marneuli municipality for the clearly stated purpose of preserving and maintaining historic sites (see paragraph 6). In the domestic proceedings, the municipality consistently maintained that the funding served that purpose (see paragraphs 14 and 29). It is also significant that, according to the case file, the applicant, unlike the Diocese, had not sought funding for that purpose. Furthermore, the Bolnisi District Court recognised the Diocese’s entitlement under section 56(b) of the Cultural Heritage Act, which required local authorities to fund the restoration and maintenance of cultural heritage sites (see paragraph 22). Finally, according to the Court of Appeal, supervision of actual expenditure, ordinarily undertaken through public auditing of municipal budgets, had not formed part of the applicant organisation’s claim and therefore fell outside the scope of the proceedings (see paragraph 33 above).

69 Accordingly, in order to determine whether the applicant organisation and the Marneuli and Hujabi Diocese were in an analogous or relevantly similar situation, the Court must examine their respective positions in relation to the subject matter of the municipal funding in issue, namely the preservation and maintenance of religious sites enjoying cultural heritage status. In this connection, it observes that, at the material time, there were 55 churches and monasteries within the Marneuli Municipality holding such a status, all of which belonged to the Georgian Church and were managed by the Marneuli and Hujabi Diocese. By contrast, only two mosques had cultural heritage status, and nothing in the case file suggests that the applicant organisation owned, administered or was otherwise responsible for maintaining either of them. On the contrary, the first-instance court expressly found that the applicant organisation had no legal or factual connection with those sites (see paragraph 22 above), a finding which was neither challenged by the applicant organisation on appeal nor subsequently called into question by the higher domestic courts of their own motion. The Supreme Court expressly reaffirmed this finding in its final decision (see paragraph 40 above). Those objective differences between the two comparators are, in the eyes of the Court, directly connected with the only purpose for which the municipal funding in issue could lawfully be granted.

70 . In the light of the foregoing, and having regard to the subject matter and purpose of the municipal funding in issue, the Court concludes that the applicant organisation was not in an analogous or relevantly similar situation to the Marneuli and Hujabi Diocese. Since, under the applicable domestic legal framework, such funding could only lawfully be granted for the preservation and maintenance of religious sites enjoying cultural heritage status, and the applicant organisation has failed to show that it either owned or was responsible, at the material time, for the management of either of the two mosques within the Marneuli municipality having that status, it cannot validly compare its position with that of the Diocese, which was clearly responsible for the maintenance of the relevant Christian cultural heritage sites. The demographic composition of the Marneuli municipality does not alter that conclusion, since the relevant comparison must be made in the light of the purpose of the funding in question rather than the religious composition of the local population. The fact that the applicant organisation and the Diocese perform comparable religious functions is also not sufficient for the purposes of Article 1 of Protocol No. 12, since the comparison must be made in relation to the specific legal context that gives rise to the alleged difference in treatment, rather than on the basis of isolated common characteristics or more general similarities between the two organisations being compared (compare, mutatis mutandis , Fábián v. Hungary [GC], no. 78117/13, §§ 121 and 129-32, 5 September 2017; Pinkas and Others , cited above, § 60; and Tulokas and Taipale v. Finland (dec.), nos. 5854/18 and 5855/18, §§ 57-59, 4 February 2025).

71 It follows that the applicant organisation’s complaint is manifestly ill ‑ founded within the meaning of Article 35 § 3 (a) of the Convention and must therefore be rejected pursuant to Article 35 § 4 thereof (see, for similar findings based on the absence of an analogous or relevantly similar situation, Milivojević v. Serbia (dec.), no. 11944/16, §§ 31-38, 5 July 2022, and Tulokas and Taipale , cited above, § 59).

For these reasons, the Court, unanimously,

Declares the application inadmissible.

Done in English and notified in writing on 5 November 2026.

Hasan Bakırcı Lorraine Schembri Orland Section Registrar President