Slovák and Tomancová v. the Czech Republic
Inadmissible
Berörda konventionsartiklar
FIFTH SECTION
Applications nos. 37464/24 and 37748/24 Milan SLOVÁK against the Czech Republic and Viktorie TOMANCOVÁ against the Czech Republic
The European Court of Human Rights (Fifth Section), sitting on 15 October 2026 as a Committee composed of:
María Elósegui , President , Kateřina Šimáčková, Gilberto Felici , judges , and Martina Keller, Deputy Section Registrar,
Having regard to:
the applications against the Czech Republic lodged with the Court under Article 34 of the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms (“the Convention”) by the applicants listed in the appended table (“the applicants”), on the various dates indicated therein;
the decision to give notice of the applications to the Czech Government (“the Government”) represented by their Agent, Mr P. Konůpka, of the Ministry of Justice;
the parties’ observations;
the decision to reject the Government’s objection to examination of the applications by a Committee;
Having deliberated, decides as follows:
SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE
1 The case concerns the refusal of the domestic administrative courts to examine the applicants’ complaints that the COVID-19 measures adopted by their university had violated their rights. The applicants also complained of a violation of their right to education and right to respect for private life as a result of those COVID-19 measures. They relied on Articles 6, 8 and 14 of the Convention and Article 2 of Protocol No. 1.
2 In the autumn semester of the 2021/22 academic year both applicants were enrolled in academic courses at Masaryk University in Brno. The first applicant was enrolled in the third semester of a degree in philosophy at the Faculty of Arts and the second applicant was a ninth-semester student enrolled in General Medicine at the Faculty of Medicine.
3 . On 18 November 2021 the Dean of the Faculty of Medicine put into place an extraordinary measure, with effect as of 24 November 2021, under which students could attend in-person classes only if they provided proof of vaccination against COVID-19, recovery from the disease within the previous 180 days, or a negative COVID-19 test not older than seven days. These measures became known as the “O-N-T system” (O – očkování (vaccination), N – nemoc (recovery), T – test (test)). Testing was made available free of charge for the students as of 25 November 2021. Students who did not meet the conditions for in-person attendance could be given alternative assignments by course coordinators.
4 On the same day the O-N-T system and similar conditions for in-person attendance in classes was also adopted in the Faculty of Arts. The measure, with several amendments, was in effect until 17 December 2021.
5 . From 22 November to 5 December 2021 the first applicant was ill and did not attend in-person classes, following his treating physician’s prescription of bed rest. Between 6 and 17 December 2021, when the O-N-T system was in force, he attended in-person classes at the Faculty of Arts, even though he had not proved that he had met the requirements of the O-N-T system. He was not excluded from classes nor was any sanction imposed on him on that account.
6 . On 19 November 2021 the second applicant sent an email to the coordinator of the week-long intensive course scheduled for the week of 22 November 2021 at the Faculty of Medicine, inquiring whether she would be allowed to attend the in-person classes if she did not meet the O-N-T conditions. The course coordinator responded that in such a case, she would not be able to attend in-person classes and would be allowed to fulfil the course requirements by alternative means. She was also offered the possibility of consulting online with the teaching staff of the course. The second applicant completed and submitted all the assigned tasks without being present at the courses.
7 On 3 February 2022 the first applicant brought an action in the Brno Regional Court, seeking protection against an allegedly unlawful and disproportionate restriction of access to in-person teaching, alleged pressure to undergo vaccination, and an unlawful requirement to disclose data concerning his health related to compliance with the O-N-T system.
8 . On 30 August 2022 the Regional Court held that there had been no unlawful interference with the first applicant’s rights. It found that even though the first applicant had not submitted any proof of his compliance with the requirements of the O-N-T system, the measures had never been enforced in respect of him and he had been able to attend in-person courses without restriction.
The first applicant lodged a cassation appeal.
9 On 14 April 2023 the Supreme Administrative Court invalidated the Regional Court’s judgment and held that the first applicant’s action was inadmissible because it lacked a plausible allegation of unlawful interference either with his right to education or his right to privacy. The first applicant lodged a constitutional appeal.
10 . On 29 July 2024 the Constitutional Court dismissed the constitutional appeal as manifestly ill-founded. It held that the Supreme Administrative Court had not erred in dismissing the action for lack of a plausible allegation of unlawful interference. The mere adoption of a measure and its general effects could not be regarded as an interference. The Constitutional Court held as follows:
...
“21. According to settled case-law, neither the mere adoption of a measure of a general nature or a legal regulation, nor the effects or consequences arising thereof, can be regarded as an ‘interference’. An action in respect of unlawful interference may be brought only against interference which specifically results from the application [of the measure or regulation] being directly aimed at an individual – not against the act itself or its general effects or consequences ... The allegation that the mere existence of the measure affected the appellant’s mental state, grades, or fears associated with being excluded from classes is therefore irrelevant for the reasons set out in the cited decisions.”
11 On 21 January 2022 the second applicant brought an action in the Brno Regional Court, complaining of an unlawful and disproportionate restriction of access to in-person teaching, alleged pressure to undergo vaccination, and an unlawful requirement to disclose data concerning her health related to compliance with the O-N-T system. The action was later amended to concern only the period between 22 and 26 November 2021.
12 . On 29 June 2022 the Regional Court delivered a judgment, holding that there had been no unlawful interference with the second applicant’s rights on account of the disputed measures. While there had been an interference with her right to education, that interference had been lawful and proportionate. As to the interference with her right to privacy, the court found that there had been no evidence that the applicant had shared any of her health data with the faculty.
The second applicant lodged a cassation appeal.
13 On 22 November 2023 the Supreme Administrative Court invalidated the Regional Court’s judgment and held that the second applicant’s action was inadmissible because it lacked a plausible allegation of unlawful interference either with her right to education or right to privacy. The email communication with the course coordinator had merely been informative in nature and not enforceable, and therefore did not constitute an interference:
“It therefore did not affect the appellant’s rights at all, let alone directly ... The Code of Administrative Justice affords protection only to an individual’s rights, not to a feeling arising from information about a state of certain affairs, a clearly unenforceable request for a person to act, or information about possible adverse consequences of failure to comply with an instruction or request ... Nor did it result in any de facto prevention of [access to] in-person classes.”
The second applicant lodged a constitutional appeal.
14 On 7 August 2024 the Constitutional Court dismissed the constitutional appeal as manifestly ill-founded. It reiterated its position that the Supreme Administrative Court had not erred in dismissing the action for lack of a plausible allegation of unlawful interference (see paragraph 10 above).
THE COURT’S ASSESSMENT
15 Having regard to the similar subject matter of the applications, the Court finds it appropriate to examine them jointly in a single decision.
16 The applicants complained, under Article 6 § 1 of the Convention, that they had been denied access to a court to have the alleged interference with their rights, caused by the COVID-19 measures adopted by their university, reviewed. They further complained under Article 8 of the Convention and Article 2 of Protocol No. 1 that those measures had interfered with their right to respect for private life and their right to education, and under Article 14 of the Convention that they had been subjected to discriminatory treatment.
17 Although the Government did not raise a plea of inadmissibility expressly on the basis of lack of significant disadvantage, the Court finds it appropriate to examine of its own motion whether the applicants’ complaints comply with the admissibility criterion set out in Article 35 § 3 (b) of the Convention (see Magomedov and Others v. Russia , nos. 33636/09 and 9 others, § 49, 28 March 2017).
18 Inspired by the principle de minimis non curat praetor , the admissibility criterion contained in Article 35 § 3 (b) of the Convention rests on the idea that a violation of a right, however real it may be from a purely legal point of view, should attain a minimum level of severity in order to warrant consideration by an international court. Following the entry into force of Protocol No. 15, the Court has been required to examine (i) whether the applicants suffered a significant disadvantage and (ii) whether respect for human rights as defined in the Convention and the Protocols thereto requires an examination of the complaints on the merits.
19 The Court notes that the grievances raised by the applicants before the administrative courts concerned their alleged inability to attend university courses in person and the alleged requirement to disclose health-related information in order to demonstrate compliance with the O-N-T system, both allegedly amounting to unfavourable treatment against them and to pressure to undergo vaccination. It observes, however, that the first applicant was never prevented from attending classes in person (see paragraph 5 above). As regards the second applicant, although she did not attend one compulsory course in person for a period of five days, she was permitted to complete alternative assignments, consult the teaching staff and ultimately fulfil all course requirements despite not being present in the class (see paragraph 6 above). Furthermore, the second applicant was given an effective opportunity to attend the class in person, as testing was available free of charge (see paragraph 3 above). The material before the Court does not show that the impugned measures produced any concrete adverse consequences for the applicants’ studies, academic progress or ability to complete their university education.
20 As regards the applicants’ complaints concerning the alleged obligation to disclose health-related data, the Court observes that the first applicant did not provide any such information to the Faculty of Arts and was nevertheless allowed to attend classes in person (see paragraph 8 above). Similarly, the second applicant failed to demonstrate in the domestic proceedings or before the Court that she had shared any information concerning her health status with the Faculty of Medicine during the relevant period (see paragraph 12 above). The applicants therefore failed to demonstrate that, during the period relevant to the applications, any health-related information concerning them was collected, processed or disclosed in a manner capable of adversely affecting their right to respect for private life. In the light of the above, the Court also finds unsubstantiated the applicants’ allegation that they were unduly disadvantaged by the O-N-T system and that its goal was to pressure them to undergo vaccination.
21 The Court notes that the applicants submitted an attendance sheet from March 2022 containing health-related information concerning the second applicant and an anonymised screenshot from May 2022 from the university information system displaying data relating to students’ compliance with the O-N-T system. However, those documents do not establish that any health-related information concerning either applicant was recorded during the period relevant to the domestic proceedings (see paragraph 12 above). In so far as the applicants may be understood as complaining separately under Article 8 of the Convention about the alleged recording of health-related information in the period covering March 2022, that complaint would in any event be inadmissible under Article 35 § 1 of the Convention for failure to exhaust effective domestic remedies.
22 Having regard to the limited practical impact of the impugned measures on the applicants and the absence of any demonstration of adverse consequences for their studies or for the protection of their data, the Court finds that the applicants did not suffer a significant disadvantage within the meaning of Article 35 § 3 (b) of the Convention on account of the COVID ‑ 19 measures themselves or on account of the administrative courts’ refusal to examine those measures’ impact at the relevant time.
23 As regards the second condition set out in Article 35 § 3 (b), the Court reiterates that it has developed extensive case-law concerning the right of access to a court (see, inter alia , Zubac v. Croatia [GC], no. 40160/12, §§ 76 ‑ 99, 5 April 2018, and Lupeni Greek Catholic Parish and Others v. Romania [GC], no. 76943/11, §§ 84-90, 29 November 2016). The present applications do not disclose any novel question concerning the interpretation or application of Article 6 § 1 of the Convention. Nor do they reveal any issue of principle concerning Articles 8 or 14 of the Convention or Article 2 of Protocol No. 1 that would require further examination by the Court.
24 In the light of the foregoing, the Court concludes that the requisite conditions for the application of Article 35 § 3 (b) of the Convention have been satisfied. It follows that the applications must be declared inadmissible pursuant to Article 35 §§ 3 (b) and 4 of the Convention.
For these reasons, the Court, unanimously,
Decides to join the applications;
Declares the applications inadmissible.
Done in English and notified in writing on 12 November 2026.
Martina Keller María Elósegui Deputy Registrar President
Appendix
List of cases:
No.
Application no.
Case name
Lodged on
Applicant Year of Birth Place of Residence Nationality
Represented by
1.
37464/24
Slovák v. the Czech Republic
05/12/2024
Milan SLOVÁK 1999 Javorník Czech
Zuzana CANDIGLIOTA
2.
37748/24
Tomancová v. the Czech Republic
13/12/2024
Viktorie TOMANCOVÁ 1997 Pozorice Czech
Zuzana CANDIGLIOTA