lagen.nu
no. 73438/17

Karvounis and Others v. Greece

Inadmissible

Domstol
European Court of Human Rights
Avgörandedatum
2026-10-20
ECLI
ECLI:CE:ECHR:2026:1020DEC007343817
Artiklar
6, 6-1, 35
Källa
hudoc.echr.coe.int

Berörda konventionsartiklar

THIRD SECTION

Application no. 73438/17 Georgios KARVOUNIS and Others against Greece

The European Court of Human Rights (Third Section), sitting on 20 October 2026 as a Committee composed of:

Peeter Roosma , President , Ioannis Ktistakis, Lətif Hüseynov , judges , and Olga Chernishova, Deputy Section Registrar,

Having regard to:

the application (no. 73438/17) against the Hellenic Republic lodged with the Court under Article 34 of the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms (“the Convention”) on 6 October 2017 by six Greek nationals (“the applicants”), listed in the appended table, who were represented by Mr K. Sintoris, a lawyer practising in Igoumenitsa;

the decision to give notice of the complaints concerning Article 6 to the Greek Government (“the Government”), represented by their Agents, Mr K. Georgiadis, Legal Counsellor, and Mrs K. Konsta, Legal representative at the State Legal Council, and to declare the remainder of the application inadmissible;

the parties’ observations;

Having deliberated, decides as follows:

SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE

1 The case concerns an alleged violation of Article 6 § 1 of the Convention on account of the dismissal of the applicants’ application for being lodged out of time.

2 By a decision of 19 May 2009, the Secretary General of the Region of Epirus declared a compulsory expropriation for the purposes of a road project. The expropriated area included properties belonging to the applicants. Pursuant to the cadastral table drawn up for the purposes of the expropriation, parts of the applicants’ properties were considered subject to self ‑ compensation on the basis of the statutory presumption that the remaining parts of the properties would benefit from the execution of the project.

3 . By judgment no. 273/2009 of 28 August 2009, the Thesprotia Court of First Instance determined the provisional compensation. Subsequently, by judgment no. 180/2010, the Corfu Court of Appeal determined the final compensation payable in respect of the expropriation.

4 . During the domestic proceedings, the applicants were represented by a lawyer.

5 On 2 November 2011 the expropriation was completed.

6 . Under Article 33 § 2 of Law no. 2971/2001, persons affected by an expropriation could, within two months of the determination of the provisional compensation, apply for the amendment of the cadastral records and seek to rebut the presumption of benefit on which the self ‑ compensation mechanism was based. Under Article 33 § 3 of Law no. 2971/2001, where a request was submitted seeking to rebut the presumption of benefit, a special committee was to be established in order to examine whether the expropriated property had in fact benefited from the execution of the project and to submit its findings to the competent court of appeal.

7 . On 12 April 2011 the applicants’ attorney sent a letter dated 11 April 2011 to the Project Construction Directorate of the Region of Epirus (hereinafter “the Directorate”). Enclosed with that letter was an application submitted by the applicants seeking the correction of the cadastral table and the establishment of the expropriation committee. The enclosed application bore the date of 12 October 2009. It further stated, inter alia, “I am enclosing this letter with which I acknowledge that this copy was received by you on today’s date (so that you do not fear that I will claim otherwise!)”.

8 On 8 March 2012 the committee established under Article 33 of Law no. 2971/2001 issued a report and transmitted the report together with the application to the Corfu Court of Appeal.

9 . By a decision of 16 January 2014, the Corfu Court of Appeal dismissed the applicants’ application for being lodged out of time. Referring to the relevant provisions of domestic law, it held that the applicants had been required to lodge their application within two months of the delivery of the judgment of the Thesprotia Court of First Instance. The applicants maintained that they had submitted the application on 12 October 2009 and relied in that regard on a postal receipt issued by the Hellenic Post for a registered letter dated 12 October 2009 and addressed to Directorate, bearing the registration number RE639627075GR. However, the court noted that the certificate did not indicate either the identity of the sender or the contents of the registered letter. It further observed that the applicants had neither tried to obtain nor produced any document capable of establishing either the sender of the letter or the date on which it had been delivered.

10 The applicants lodged an appeal on points of law, arguing that the Court of Appeal had incorrectly assessed the evidential value and content of the postal receipt produced by them.

11 . On 17 February 2017 the Supreme Court dismissed the applicants’ appeal on points of law and upheld the Corfu Court of Appeal’s decision (judgment no. 289/2017).

12 The applicants complained that they had been deprived of access to a court, as provided for in Article 6 § 1 of the Convention, owing to an overly restrictive interpretation of the domestic procedural rules.

THE COURT’S ASSESSMENT

13 The applicants submitted that they had lodged their appeal before the Directorate within the prescribed time-limit. They maintained that the application had been sent by registered post on 12 October 2009 and they relied on a postal receipt bearing the registration number RE639627075GR and the date of dispatch. They argued that this evidence was sufficient to establish compliance with the statutory time-limit and that they should not have been made to bear the consequences of any subsequent failure on the part of the administration to register, process or retain the application (see paragraph 9 above).

14 The Government argued that the postal receipt did not identify either the sender or the contents of the item allegedly dispatched and was therefore insufficient to establish that the application in question had been lodged within the prescribed period. In their view, the applicants had failed to produce evidence capable of demonstrating that the application had actually been received by the competent authority in October 2009.

15 The general principles on the right of access to a court and, in particular, on access to superior courts were summarised in Zubac v. Croatia ([GC], no. 40160/12, §§ 76 ‑ 99, 5 April 2018) and Albuquerque Fernandes v. Portugal (no. 50160/13, § 70, 12 January 2021).

16 Where the procedural error in question occurred only on one side, that of the applicant or the relevant authorities, notably the court(s), as the case may be, the Court would normally be inclined to place the burden on the one who produced it (see Tence v. Slovenia , no. 37242/14, § 35, 31 May 2016; Platakou v. Greece , no. 38460/97, § 39, ECHR 2001-I; and Sotiris and Nikos Koutras ATTEE v. Greece , no. 39442/98, § 21, ECHR 2000-XII; contrast Rodriguez Valin v. Spain , no. 47792/99, § 28, 11 October 2001).

17 In the present case, it has not been disputed by the parties that, under Article 33 § 2 of Law no. 2971/2001, persons affected by an expropriation could seek the correction of the cadastral table and the rebuttal of the presumption of benefit by submitting an application to the competent authority within two months of the determination of the provisional compensation (see paragraph 6 above). The parties disagreed, however, as to whether the applicants had in fact complied with that requirement.

18 Turning to the circumstances of the present case, the Court notes that the statutory time-limit and the procedure for seeking the correction of the cadastral records were clearly prescribed by domestic law (see paragraph 6 above) and were therefore foreseeable for the applicants, who were represented by a lawyer throughout the proceedings (see paragraph 4 above). It observes that the domestic courts examined the evidence relied on by the applicants in support of their claim that the application had been lodged in time. In particular, they noted that the postal receipt produced by the applicants did not indicate either the identity of the sender or the contents of the registered letter. They further observed that the applicants had failed to produce any document capable of establishing either who had sent the letter or the date on which it had been received by the Directorate (contrast Tence , cited abov e, § 35). On the basis of the material before them, they concluded that the applicants had failed to prove that the appeal had been lodged within the prescribed time-limit (see paragraphs 9 and 11 above). In that regard, the Court cannot discern any excessive formalism in the approach adopted by the domestic courts.

19 The Court also attaches weight to the fact that the applicants’ lawyer addressed a letter to the Directorate on 12 April 2011, that is, more than seventeen months after the expiry of the relevant time-limit (see paragraph 7 above). In the accompanying letter, he acknowledged receipt of that copy by the authority “on today’s date”, without referring to any previous submission of the application. Furthermore, the applicants have not shown that, during the period between 12 October 2009 and 12 April 2011, they contacted the competent authority to inquire about the progress of the proceedings. This is particularly noteworthy given that, under the relevant domestic legislation, a decision on their application was to be taken within three months. In these circumstances, the Court considers that the applicants failed to take the steps reasonably required to safeguard their procedural interests. Accordingly, to the extent that the failure to establish the timely lodging of the appeal resulted from their own omissions rather than from any conduct attributable to the authorities, they must bear the consequences of that failure

20 Having regard to the reasons advanced by the domestic courts and to the material available to it, the Court finds no indication that the domestic courts’ assessment was arbitrary or manifestly unreasonable. Nor does it discern any appearance of disproportionate formalism or any impairment of the very essence of the applicants’ right of access to a court.

21 It follows that the application must be rejected in accordance with Article 35 § 4 of the Convention.

For these reasons, the Court, unanimously,

Declares the application inadmissible.

Done in English and notified in writing on 12 November 2026.

Olga Chernishova Peeter Roosma Deputy Registrar President

Appendix

List of applicants:

Application no. 73438/17

No.

Applicant’s name

Year of birth

Nationality

Place of residence

1.

Georgios KARVOUNIS

1958

Greek

Igoumenitsa

2.

Theodoros GATSELOS

1937

Greek

Igoumenitsa

3.

Andreas GOGOLOS

1951

Greek

Igoumenitsa

4.

Georgios GOGOLOS

1948

Greek

Igoumenitsa

5.

Stefanos PAPIGKIOTIS

1961

Greek

Ioannina

6.

Michail TOULAS

1942

Greek

Igoumenitsa