Atikyan v. Armenia
Inadmissible
Berörda konventionsartiklar
FIFTH SECTION
Application no. 25992/16 Aram ATIKYAN against Armenia
The European Court of Human Rights (Fifth Section), sitting on 15 October 2026 as a Committee composed of:
Andreas Zünd , President , Mykola Gnatovskyy, Vahe Grigoryan , judges , and Martina Keller, Deputy Section Registrar,
Having regard to:
the application (no. 25992/16) against the Republic of Armenia lodged with the Court under Article 34 of the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms (“the Convention”) on 2 May 2016 by an Armenian national, Mr Aram Atikyan (“the applicant”), who was born in 1983 and lives in Spitak, and was initially represented by Mr A. Harutyunyan and subsequently by Ms M. Sahakyan, lawyers practising in Vanadzor;
the decision to give notice of the application to the Armenian Government (“the Government”), represented by their Agent, Mr Y. Kirakosyan, Representative of the Republic of Armenia on International Legal Matters;
the parties’ observations;
Having deliberated, decides as follows:
SUBJECT MATTER OF THE CASE
1 The application concerns the alleged de facto expropriation of the applicant’s house and plot of land without compensation.
2 The applicant owned a house and a plot of land, measuring respectively 39.4 sq. m and 460 sq. m, in the town of Spitak.
3 . On 27 January 2005 the mayor of Spitak issued a decision allocating a plot of land measuring 3,600 sq. m to the Ministry of Urban Development for the purpose of constructing the town sports school. The allocated land also included the applicant’s plot of land.
4 . On 26 May 2005 the mayor of Spitak issued a building permit for the construction of the sports school on the allocated land.
5 . On 9 June 2005 the Spitak municipality (“the municipality”) and the applicant signed an agreement whereby the applicant undertook to have his house demolished and to transfer his plot of land to the municipality for construction purposes. In exchange, the municipality undertook to provide the applicant, by 2007, with ownership of a two-room flat. The agreement was neither notarised nor registered with the State Committee of the Real Estate Cadastre.
6 Subsequently, the applicant’s house was demolished, and a sports school was constructed on the land in question, the construction having been completed on 10 April 2006. However, the applicant was not provided with the promised flat.
7 On 13 October 2010 the applicant lodged a civil claim with the Lori Regional Court against the municipality, seeking a two-room flat as compensation in exchange for his property on the basis of the agreement of 9 June 2005.
8 On 3 February 2012 the Regional Court dismissed the applicant’s claim, finding that the agreement was null and void because it had not been notarised, as required by the Civil Code, and could not therefore produce legal consequences.
9 The applicant appealed against that judgment, but his appeal was dismissed, and his further appeal on points of law was declared inadmissible by the Court of Cassation for lack of merit on 27 June 2012.
10 In 2013 the applicant lodged claims with the Administrative Court against the municipality and the Ministry of Urban Development, seeking to have the land allocation decision and the building permit (see paragraphs 3 and 4 above) declared null and void, and requesting the demolition of the sports school.
11 On 8 December 2014 the Administrative Court partly granted the applicant’s claim and declared the land allocation decision and the building permit null and void in so far as they concerned the applicant’s plot of land, finding that those administrative acts had granted manifestly unlawful rights over that land to the Ministry of Urban Development. However, the court dismissed the applicant’s claim for the demolition of the sports school.
12 The applicant appealed against that judgment, and the appeal was dismissed by the Administrative Court of Appeal, while his further appeal on points of law was declared inadmissible by the Court of Cassation for lack of merit on 28 October 2015.
13 . The applicant subsequently sought compensation from the municipality for the damage allegedly caused by the annulled administrative acts. His claims were examined in two sets of proceedings before the municipal authorities, followed by two sets of judicial proceedings. During those proceedings, the applicant withdrew his claim for pecuniary damages, stating that he had received compensation for pecuniary damage under Government Decree no. 338-N of 30 March 2017 (see paragraph 14 below), and pursued only his claims in respect of non-pecuniary damage and unjust enrichment arising from the use of his land. Those claims were ultimately dismissed by the Administrative Court of Appeal on 16 June 2023. The applicant did not lodge a further appeal.
14 . On 30 March 2017 the Government adopted Decree No. 338-N, which entitled the applicant to 5,500,000 Armenian drams (AMD – equivalent to approximately 10,500 euros at the material time), under a financial support programme, subject to the conditions that he freely transfer his plot of land to the Spitak Community and renounce future housing claims against State or local self-government authorities.
15 On 3 May 2017 the applicant lodged an application with the regional authorities, expressing a wish to benefit from the financial support programme and giving his consent to its terms. At the same time, he submitted a notarised statement renouncing future housing claims against State or local self-government authorities.
16 . On 6 May 2017 the applicant and the Spitak municipality signed a notarised agreement, under which the applicant freely transferred the ownership of his land and house to the municipality. Consequently, the applicant was paid AMD 5,500,000.
THE COURT’S ASSESSMENT
17 The applicant complained under Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 to the Convention that he had been deprived of his right to peaceful enjoyment of his house and land and that he had not been provided with the promised two ‑ room flat in compensation. He also complained under Article 13 of the Convention that he had not had at his disposal an effective domestic remedy to seek compensation for the violation of his property rights.
18 The Government argued, inter alia , that the application was inadmissible as an abuse of the right of individual application because the applicant had failed to inform the Court of new developments in his case.
19 The general principles concerning the rejection of an application on grounds of abuse of the right of individual application have been summarised in Gross v. Switzerland ([GC], no. 67810/10, § 28, ECHR 2014). In particular, the Court reiterates that the submission of incomplete and thus misleading information may amount to an abuse of the right of application, especially if the information concerns the very core of the case and no sufficient explanation has been provided for the failure to disclose that information. The same applies if important new developments have occurred during the proceedings before the Court and where, despite being expressly required to do so by Rule 47 § 7 of the Rules of Court, the applicant has failed to disclose that information to the Court, thereby preventing it from ruling on the case in full knowledge of the facts (ibid.).
20 The present application was lodged with the Court on 2 May 2016. By a letter from the Registry of the Court dated 4 August 2016, the applicant was asked to keep the Court informed of any significant developments in the case. Subsequently, important developments occurred in the case. In particular, in May 2017 the applicant freely transferred the ownership of his land and the house to the municipality, renounced future housing claims against State or local self-government authorities and was paid AMD 5,500,000 in compensation (see paragraphs 14-16 above). On 12 April 2021 the President of the Section to which the case had been allocated, unaware of those developments, decided to give notice of the application to the Armenian Government. The Court learned of those developments only from the Government’s observations of 10 November 2021 – that is, more than four and a half years after the developments had occurred.
21 Those were important developments that concerned the very core of the case, specifically the applicant’s property rights and the alleged lack of compensation. The applicant, who was represented by counsel, failed to inform the Court of those developments.
22 The Court cannot accept the applicant’s argument that he had merely been provided with financial assistance which he had not considered compensation in respect of pecuniary damage. The Court notes that, regardless of what the programme was called, the applicant received the amount in exchange for freely transferring his property to the Spitak municipality and renouncing future housing claims. Moreover, even the applicant himself explicitly stated before the domestic authorities that he had received compensation in respect of pecuniary damage and did not pursue that part of his claim (see paragraph 13 above). Furthermore, the applicant’s notarised statement renouncing future housing claims against State or local self-government authorities could also affect the Court’s assessment of his victim status (see Rauš and Rauš Radovanović v. Croatia (dec.), no. 43603/05, 2 October 2008, and Aykut and Others v. Turkey (dec.), no . 22473/03, 15 September 2009, and the references cited therein).
23 In the light of the circumstances above, the Court considers that the applicant’s failure to disclose essential developments in his case constitutes an abuse of the right of individual application (see Komatinović v. Serbia (dec.), no. 75381/10, 29 January 2013; Gevorgyan and Others v. Armenia (dec.), no. 66535/10, §§ 31-39, 14 January 2020; and Safaryan v. Armenia (dec.), no. 16346/10, §§ 24-31, 14 January 2020).
24 It follows that the application must be rejected in accordance with Article 35 §§ 3 and 4 of the Convention.
For these reasons, the Court, unanimously,
Declares the application inadmissible.
Done in English and notified in writing on 12 November 2026.
Martina Keller Andreas Zünd Deputy Registrar President