Nvo Mans v. Montenegro
Inadmissible
Berörda konventionsartiklar
FIRST SECTION
Application no. 2266/23 NVO MANS against Montenegro
The European Court of Human Rights (First Section), sitting on 13 October 2026 as a Chamber composed of:
Erik Wennerström , President , Ivana Jelić, Frédéric Krenc, Davor Derenčinović, Alain Chablais, Artūrs Kučs, Anna Adamska-Gallant , judges and Ilse Freiwirth, Section Registrar,
Having regard to the above application lodged on 30 December 2022,
Having regard to the observations submitted by the respondent Government and the observations in reply submitted by the applicant,
Having deliberated, decides as follows:
1 The applicant organisation, NVO MANS, is a Montenegrin non-governmental organisation (NGO) registered in 2000 in Podgorica. It was represented before the Court by Mr P. Gluščević, a lawyer practising in Nikšić.
2 The Montenegrin Government (“the Government”) were represented by their Agent at the time, Ms. K. Peković.
3 . The applicant organisation is a well-established NGO. Its website specifies that it fights corruption and organised crime affecting Montenegro, and its proclaimed goals are reducing the scope for the operation of organised crime; reducing high-level corruption; increasing the transparency and accountability of institutions; and improving civic oversight of their work (see mans.co.me/en/ [1] ).
4 The facts of the case, as submitted by the parties, may be summarised as follows.
5 On 30 January 2012 the Prime Minister of Montenegro issued a decision classifying audio-recordings ( tonski zapis ) of government sessions ( sjednica Vlade ) as “internal”. The decision specified who had access to such recordings and why it was necessary to classify them in that way, and referred to the relevant Rules of Procedure ( Poslovnik ) of the Government of Montenegro and the Classified Information Act ( Zakon o tajnosti podataka ).
6 On 15 January 2014 the Prime Minister of Montenegro extended by two years the period during which audio-recordings of government sessions would remain classified.
7 . On 28 December 2016 the Commission for Reviewing the Classification of Audio-Recordings of Government Sessions (“the Commission”) conducted a periodic review of the classification in question, in accordance with point 4 of the first paragraph of section 19b of the Classified Information Act (see paragraph 47 below). The Commission found that the interest in performing an official duty and preventing the disclosure of information which related to, inter alia , consultations within and between various authorities and the determination of their opinions ( utvrđivanjem stavova ) outweighed the public interest in knowing what information those audio-recordings contained. The Commission further found that within the meaning of section 17 of the Free Access to Information Act (“FAIA”), there was no overriding public interest in disclosing such information (see paragraph 36 below), and that allowing access to information contained in such audio-recordings could have adverse consequences for the foreign, monetary and economic policy of Montenegro, as it could affect the quality of the government’s functioning. It also established that making the information in question classified did not amount to covering up a criminal offence, corruption, abuse of office, an unlawful act, the unlawful use of public funds or abuse of a public function. The Commission referred to a number of provisions of the FAIA, the Classified Information Act, and the Government Rules of Procedure.
8 . In particular, the Commission found that during sessions, members of government disclosed certain information and expressed their opinions about proposals and findings in order to adopt high-quality, sustainable decisions, and that the disclosure of such information and opinions could affect the quality of government functioning and State policy. Audio-recordings of government sessions were made in order to ensure that minutes and conclusions were properly prepared. An audio-recording of a government session did not constitute an official document ( nema formu zvaničnog akta ), but was instead a record of a discussion about certain decisions on the foreign, monetary and economic policy of Montenegro which were adopted in the course of official duties and related to, inter alia , consultations within and between various authorities in relation to determining their opinions, producing official documents and proposing various decisions. It did not have the signature of an authorised person or an archive number, so could not be considered information within the meaning of section 10 of the FAIA (see paragraph 32 below). The Commission also noted that the proposals examined and the material adopted during government sessions, as well as the minutes of those sessions, were published on the government homepage, and the public was also informed about them via press releases. The Commission held that an audio-recording was not an official document determining the rights and duties and legal interests of physical or legal persons, nor did it interfere with any rights or direct personal interests provided for by law; it was, instead, a record of a discussion held during a government session.
9 . Accordingly, the Commission considered that such audio-recordings should be classified, as their availability could have adverse consequences for the foreign, monetary and economic policy of Montenegro. In addition, the discussions and opinions expressed in those recordings did not contain information which would make the public interest in disclosing the information an overriding interest. An audio-recording of that nature had no legal or other effects on citizens; only documents which had been adopted had such an effect, and all documents like that were published, apart from the ones which were classified. Therefore, restricting the right of access to audio-recordings did not affect the public’s right to know about information which allowed it to exercise democratic control over the government, as provided for in section 5 of the FAIA (see paragraph 30 below). The Commission concluded that disclosing the audio-recordings could affect the quality of the government’s performance, and that the interest in preventing the adverse consequences for the government’s functioning that would arise as a result of such disclosure was more important than the interest in free access to information. The Commission also recommended that the classification level of such audio-recordings should be higher than “internal”.
10 . On 29 December 2016 the Prime Minister issued a decision changing the classification level of audio-recordings of government sessions from “internal” to “confidential”. The decision reiterated most of the Commission’s findings (see paragraphs 8-9 above). It also specified that audio-recordings of government sessions where members discussed and harmonised positions on the foreign, monetary and economic policy of Montenegro did not contain information which would make the public interest in disclosure – either in whole or in part – an overriding interest within the meaning of section 17 of the FAIA. The decision further noted that the interest in preventing adverse consequences for the performance of government functions that would arise by disclosing confidential information was more important than the interest in free access to information. It took into account that section 12 of the Classified Information Act provided that the basis for determining the level of classified information was the content of that information and its importance to security and defence and to the foreign, monetary and economic policy of Montenegro, and that information whose disclosure could have adverse consequences for Montenegro’s foreign, monetary and economic policy was classified as “confidential”. The decision referred to, inter alia , section 21 of the Classified Information Act, section 2 of the Decree on the Government, rule 68 of the Government Rules of Procedure, rule 9 of the Rules on the Government Web Portal and Sub-Portals, section 1 of the Decision on the Publication of Material from Government Sessions, and point 2 of the first paragraph of section 14 of the FAIA (see paragraphs 48-49, 55, 58, and 34 below).
11 . On 16 March 2017 the government held a regular session. According to a press release from that session which was published on the government website and submitted by the applicant organisation, the government adopted: a series of bills on amendments to various Acts (the Health Insurance Act, the Compulsory Social Insurance Contributions Act, the Expropriation Act, and the Explosive Materials Act); amendments to a decree on the General Secretariat of the government (“the General Secretariat”) and a decree on criteria for the internal organisation and systematisation of jobs in the civil service; a decree on the Prime Minister’s Private Office; a decision on the temporary restriction of the export of certain categories of timber; information on a long-term loan to provide missing funds for the 2017 budget, involving a proposed loan agreement between the Ministry of Finance and a private bank in the amount of 15 million euros; a report on the situation of the Montenegrin army in 2016; and a report on the implementation of a national programme for the development of sport in 2016. The same press release also stated that in the context of regular reporting on the progress of works on part of a motorway, the Minister of Transport and Admiralty (“the Minister of Transport”) had provided an oral report ( podnio je usmenu informaciju ) on rights over some real estate being transferred from municipalities to the State. The press release also specified that one item on the agenda (a decree on the organisation and work of the civil service) had been adjourned and two other items had been withdrawn from the agenda (one relating to the construction, reconstruction and maintenance of State roads, and another one about a forest concession). The press release also contained a brief description of most of the items.
12 . On 20 March 2017 the applicant organisation lodged a request with the General Secretariat, seeking a copy of the audio-recording of the government session held on 16 March 2017. The request contained only the applicant organisation’s postal address and email address to which the decision and relevant information were to be sent.
13 On 31 March 2017 the request was dismissed on the grounds that audio-recordings of government sessions had been declared “confidential” by the Prime Minister’s decision of 29 December 2016 (see paragraph 10 above), and that when necessary, they could be used by members of government in the performance of their functions and by employees of the General Secretariat in the performance of their duties. The decision of the General Secretariat also found that the level “confidential” was for information whose disclosure could harm the foreign, monetary and economic policy of Montenegro, and that the interest in protecting the government from adverse consequences which would arise as a result of the disclosure of the information in question outweighed the interest in free access to information. The decision referred to the second paragraph of rule 68 of the Government Rules of Procedure, section 12 of the Classified Information Act, and point 2 of the first paragraph of section 14 of the FAIA (see paragraphs 55, 44 and 34 below).
14 . On 26 April 2017 the applicant organisation initiated an administrative dispute. In its claim, it maintained that the decision of the General Secretariat had been arbitrary and had lacked reasoning, that it had been in breach of Articles 6 and 10 of the Convention, and that the General Secretariat had acted contrary to section 3, section 4, the first and second paragraphs of section 10, and paragraph 4 of section 12 of the Classified Information Act (see paragraphs 39-40, 42 and 44 below). The applicant organisation submitted in particular that the public interest in disclosure was indisputable, as the audio-recordings in question contained information relating to the examination and adoption of decisions on questions relevant to all citizens, which was why that interest outweighed any other interest. The applicant organisation maintained that the disputed decision had lacked reasoning as to how it had been assessed that the disclosure of the requested information could jeopardise the security and defence of Montenegro and the country’s foreign, monetary and economic interests, and argued that it had not been proved that publishing the information in question would harm any interest. The applicant organisation referred to Társaság a Szabadságjogokért v. Hungary (no. 37374/05, 14 April 2009) and submitted that the arbitrary restriction of access to information was a form of indirect censorship.
15 . The applicant organisation further maintained that information could not be declared confidential if the purpose of such a declaration was to hide a criminal offence, the exceeding of authority or abuse of office, or some other unlawful decision or conduct or administrative error. It argued that classifying all audio-recordings of government sessions in general could only be in the interest of covering up corruption and abuses, and that was why the public nature of government procedure was prescribed. The applicant organisation submitted that its access to the requested information had been unlawfully restricted, and that mere reference to point 2 of the first paragraph of section 14 of the FAIA did not constitute a sufficient reason for such a restriction. In relation to that provision of the FAIA, the applicant organisation referred to decision Uvp.br.372/15 of the Supreme Court, submitting that it had found that restricting access to information merely by citing section 14 of the FAIA could not constitute a sufficient reason for restricting access to information. The applicant organisation did not submit that decision to the Court along with the case file.
16 On 14 February 2018 the Administrative Court of Montenegro dismissed the applicant’s administrative claim as unfounded. It found that the Commission had conducted the relevant review on 28 December 2016 and had established that the interest in performing official duties and preventing the disclosure of information relating to consultations within and between various authorities outweighed the public interest in knowing what information such audio-recordings contained, and that access to the audio-recordings could cause adverse consequences for the foreign, monetary and economic policy of Montenegro. The court referred to section 3 of the Classified Information Act and section 16 of the FAIA (see paragraph 39 and 35 below), and in particular to the fact that access to information could be restricted if disclosure of that information could have adverse consequences for an interest that was of greater importance than the public interest in knowing about that information.
17 . On 5 April 2018 the applicant organisation lodged a request for judicial review. It submitted that it had not been established exactly what interest had been more important than the public interest in knowing about the information in question. In particular, the court had provided no reasons for why it had considered that “consultations within and between authorities” could jeopardise the foreign, monetary and economic policy of Montenegro or how the interest in performing official duties would be jeopardised; nor had it stated what adverse consequences for the foreign, monetary and economic policy of Montenegro could arise if the public learnt how the government worked and adopted decisions in its sessions – decisions which were of interest to all citizens. The applicant organisation submitted that it was indisputable that the work of the government was public and that citizens had the right to know how decisions were made. It maintained that adopting decisions in secret created an ideal environment for corruption and decisions which were harmful to citizens. The applicant organisation further maintained that having a general restriction on all audio-recordings of government sessions was unlawful, as it was contrary to the FAIA and the Constitution, as well as Article 10 of the Convention and the Council of Europe Convention on Access to Official Documents. It submitted that arbitrarily ( paušalno ) making such audio-recordings classified and changing their classification level had an effect on all requests for access to information contained in those audio-recordings.
18 On 31 May 2018 the Supreme Court of Montenegro dismissed the applicant’s request for judicial review. It found that the Administrative Court had given sufficient and clear reasons for its decision and that there had been no breach of the applicant organisation’s rights under Articles 6 and 10 of the Convention. In particular, it found that the FAIA provided for the possibility of restricting access to information, including where the disclosure of information would jeopardise an interest which was of greater importance than the public interest in knowing about the information in question, and referred to sections 14 and 16 of that Act (see paragraphs 34-35 below). The court also referred to the Commission’s review and its decision of 29 December 2016, after which the classification of audio-recordings of government sessions had been changed from “internal” to “confidential”, and the second paragraph of rule 68 of the Rules of Procedure (see paragraphs 10 above and 55 below). It also noted that the Decision on the Publication of Material from Government Sessions defined which material from the government’s sessions was published on the government’s website and how it was published (see paragraph 59-61 below).
19 . On 26 June 2018 the applicant organisation lodged a constitutional appeal, complaining, inter alia , under Article 10 of the Convention. In particular, it submitted that it had been deprived of its right to access and impart information relating to how the executive power adopted decisions which were of importance to all citizens and consequently subject to public control. It also maintained that the decisions of the Administrative Court and the Supreme Court had been arbitrary and had lacked reasoning, and that the Supreme Court, instead of examining the lawfulness of the executive power’s act of classifying information relating to its work, had adopted the position that the executive power could arbitrarily decide what information relating to its work to hide from the public.
20 On 5 May 2022 the Constitutional Court dismissed the applicant’s constitutional appeal. The judgment was served on the applicant on 14 September 2022. As regards Article 10 of the Convention, the court referred to the criteria set out and the findings in Magyar Helsinki Bizottság v. Hungary ([GC], no. 18030/11, 8 November 2016). It also referred to Társaság a Szabadságjogokért v. Hungary (no. 37374/05, 14 April 2009), and Youth Initiative for Human Rights v. Serbia (no. 48135/06, 25 June 2013). It also noted section 3 of the FAIA and referred to section 7, section 14 and the first paragraph of section 16 of that Act (see paragraphs 29, 31, and 34-35 below), and stated that the FAIA required that the public interest in disclosure be examined every time access to information was sought.
21 . In particular, the Constitutional Court of Montenegro found that the applicant organisation in the present case was an NGO which could have the role of a public watchdog, and that the question was whether refusing its request for information had amounted to an interference with its rights under Article 10. The court noted that the applicant had not specified what the purpose of its request had been, nor had it argued that by requesting that information it had wanted to contribute in some way to a debate of public interest or impart that information to interested members of the public. Nor had the organisation argued that the lack of disclosure had prevented it from participating in a public debate on some question of public interest and thereby performing its role as a public watchdog.
22 The Constitutional Court further found that the Commission had conducted a relevant review in accordance with the first paragraph of section 16 of the FAIA (see paragraph 35 below) and had established that the interest in preventing adverse consequences for the government’s functioning outweighed the public interest in knowing about the information in question. In other words, the nature of the information which had been requested was such that it had already been established by law that such information could be exempted from disclosure, whereas the applicant organisation had not attempted to show that there was a public interest justifying why that information should nevertheless be published. In view of that, the court held that the lower courts had carefully examined the matter and had given clear reasons which could not be considered arbitrary.
23 The Constitutional Court also found that as the applicant organisation had not alleged that the requested information related to a specific activity or question of public interest, its role within the meaning of the relevant criterion established in Magyar Helsinki Bizottság could not be examined. The court also established that it could not be concluded that the requested information had been necessary for some of the applicant organisation’s activities as an NGO which would contribute to a debate of obvious public interest.
24 Taking all those factors into account, the Constitutional Court concluded that the refusal by the relevant domestic body and the courts to allow access to the information in question had not “caused harm” ( nijesu ... naškodili ) to the applicant organisation’s right of free access to information, due to which there had been no interference with the applicant organisation’s right under Article 10 of the Convention.
25 Article 24 provides that guaranteed human rights and freedoms may be restricted only by law, within the scope permitted by the Constitution and to the extent necessary to satisfy the purpose for which the restriction is permitted, in an open and free democratic society. Restrictions may not be imposed for purposes other than those for which they are prescribed.
26 Article 47 guarantees the right to freedom of expression and provides that it may be restricted only by another’s right to dignity, reputation and honour, or if public morality or the security of Montenegro is threatened.
27 Article 51 provides that everyone has the right of access to information held by State bodies and organisations exercising public authority. The right of access to information may be restricted if it is in the interest of the protection of life; public health; morality and privacy; the conduct of criminal proceedings; the security and defence of Montenegro; or foreign, monetary and economic policy.
28 The first paragraph of section 1 of the FAIA provides that the right to access information and to re-use information in the possession of public authorities shall be exercised in accordance with the manner and procedure prescribed by this Act. Point 2 of the second paragraph of section 1 of the FAIA, in force as of 17 May 2017, provides that the provisions of this Act do not apply to information which must be kept classified in accordance with the law governing classified information.
29 . Section 3 provides that any national or foreign natural person or legal entity has the right to access information without being obliged to state the reasons for the request or explain the interest in requesting the information.
30 . Section 5 provides that access to information ensures that the public knows about information held by the authorities, so that the public may exercise democratic control over the government and exercise human rights and freedoms.
31 . Section 7 provides that access to information is in the public interest and may be restricted only for the purpose of protecting the interests specified in this Act.
32 . Section 10 provides that information is a document or part of a document in written, printed, video, audio, electronic or any other form, including copies thereof, regardless of its content, source (author), time of creation or classification system. Access to information includes the right to request and receive information, regardless of the purpose of that request and the data contained in that information.
33 Section 13 provides that a public authority must allow a natural person or a legal entity requesting access to information to access the information or part of that information which is in its possession, except in the cases provided for by this Act.
34 . Point 2 of the first paragraph of section 14 provides that a public authority may restrict access to information or part of that information in the interests of security and defence, and the foreign, monetary and economic policy of Montenegro, in accordance with the regulations governing classified information “designated as having a certain classification level”.
35 . The first paragraph of section 16 provides that access to information is restricted if disclosure of information would significantly jeopardise the interests referred to in section 14 of this Act, that is, if there is a possibility that the disclosure of information would cause adverse consequences for an interest that is more important than the public interest in knowing about that information, unless there is an overriding public interest prescribed by section 17 of this Act.
36 . Section 17 provides that an overriding public interest in disclosing information or part of that information exists when the requested information contains data that reasonably ( osnovano ) indicate
(1) corruption, non-compliance with regulations, the unlawful use of public funds, or abuse of power in the performance of a public function;
(2) a suspicion that a criminal offence has been committed, or the existence of reasons for contesting a court decision;
(3) the unlawful acquisition or expenditure of public funds;
(4) a threat to public security;
(5) a threat to life;
(6) a threat to public health; or
(7) a threat to the environment.
A public authority must grant access to the information referred to in section 14 of this Act, or part of that information, when there is an overriding public interest in disclosing such information.
37 . Section 24 provides that if access to part of a piece of information is restricted in accordance with section 14 of this Act, the public authority in question must provide access to the rest of the information requested by providing the person who requested it with a copy of that information, after deleting the part of the information to which access is restricted. In such a case, the part of the information to which access is restricted must be marked as “deleted” and information on the extent of the deletion (line, paragraph and page numbers) will be provided.
38 . The second paragraph of section 44 provides that a court has the right to assess if a public authority has properly classified data contained in requested information in accordance with the Act governing classified information.
39 . Section 3 of the Classified Information Act provides that classified information is information whose disclosure to an unauthorised person would or could cause adverse consequences for the security and defence of Montenegro and the country’s foreign, monetary and economic policy. Data must be designated as classified in accordance with the conditions and procedure prescribed by this Act.
40 . Section 4 provides that information cannot be designated as classified in order to conceal a criminal offence which has been committed; endangerment of the environment; the restriction of competition; the exceeding of or abuse of authority; or an unlawful decision, conduct or administrative error on the part of the authorities.
41 Section 6 provides that access to classified information is restricted and may be granted in accordance with the manner and conditions specified by this Act, regulations adopted on the basis of this Act, and international agreements concluded by Montenegro.
42 . Section 10 provides that information can be designated as classified if this is necessary in a democratic society and if the interest referred to in section 3 of this Act is more important than the interest in free access to information. The second paragraph of section 10 provides that a person authorised to determine the level of classification of information designates information as classified and determines its level of classification by means of a reasoned decision. The third paragraph of section 10 provides that notwithstanding the second paragraph of that section, a person authorised to determine the level of classification of information, in a body where the same type of classified information is continuously and repeatedly produced, may classify such information and determine its level of classification by means of a special decision.
43 Section 11 provides that the classified information referred to in section 3 of this Act shall be classified as top secret, secret, confidential and internal.
44 . Section 12 provides that the basis for determining the level of classification of information is the content of the classified information and its importance to the security and defence of Montenegro and the country’s foreign, monetary and economic policy. The fourth and fifth paragraphs of section 12 provide that the classification level “confidential” is assigned to information whose disclosure could have adverse consequences for the security and interests of Montenegro, and the classification level “internal” is assigned to information whose disclosure would have adverse effects on the functioning of a body.
45 . The first paragraph of section 18 provides that when determining the level of classification of information, the person authorised to determine that level also determines how the information will be declassified by setting a date for such declassification which is within the time frame specified in section 19a of this Act, and by specifying an event which will trigger the information becoming declassified.
46 Points 3 and 4 of the first paragraph of section 19a provide that if the declassification of information has not been defined in accordance with section 18 of this Act, the classified status of that information expires after five years for information classified as “confidential”, and after two years for information classified as “internal”. The third paragraph of the same section provides that exceptionally, a person authorised to determine the level of classification of information may extend the classification period if, prior to the expiry of the periods specified, he or she establishes that there are reasons relating to security which justify such an extension, but for no longer than the periods provided for in the first paragraph of this section.
47 . Points 3 and 4 of the first paragraph of section 19b provide that a periodic review of the classification of information – on the basis of which the level of classification of that information may be modified, the information may be declassified, or the period of classification may be extended – is carried out by a commission established by the head of a relevant body (a State authority, a body of State administration, a body of local self ‑ government units, and other legal entities exercising public powers) at least once every three years for information classified as “confidential”, and at least once a year for information classified as “internal”.
48 . Section 21 provides that the classification level of information may be changed. Reclassification may concern a whole piece of information or the part of it which was designated as classified. Only an authorised person who has the power to determine the level of classification may reclassify information.
49 . Section 2 of the Decree on the Government of Montenegro provides that the government is accountable to the Parliament of Montenegro for the conduct of the internal and foreign policy of Montenegro, for the enforcement of laws and other regulations, and for the functioning of State administration bodies.
50 Section 4 provides that the work of the government is public, and that it has a website on which it publishes information and data concerning its activities. The same section provides that the government is obliged to ensure public access to its work in accordance with the law governing free access to information of public importance and the Government Rules of Procedure.
51 . Sections 8 and 9, in so far as relevant, provide that the government conducts its work and adopts decisions at its sessions, provided that more than half of its members are present at the session, and that, save in some exceptional situations, it adopts decisions by a majority vote of the members present.
52 Section 17 provides that the government adopts decrees, decisions, strategies, declarations, rulings, conclusions and other official decisions.
53 Section 20 provides that the government must adopt Rules of Procedure to regulate in more detail its organisation and working methods, in accordance with this Decree.
54 . Rule 63 of the Government Rules of Procedure, in so far as relevant, provides that the minutes of government sessions are kept and contain, in particular, the ordinal number and date of the session, the name of the chairperson, the time the session started and concluded, the names of the members of government who were present and absent, the names of persons who participated in the session, the names of persons who participated in the session by invitation, the agenda for the session, and the decisions made by the government on each item on the agenda.
55 . The first paragraph of rule 68 provides that audio-recordings of government sessions are made. The second paragraph which was in force until 26 June 2015 provided that the Prime Minister or the government could determine an appropriate classification level for such a recording or any part of it. The second paragraph as amended and in force since 26 June 2015 provides that when necessary, audio-recordings may be used by members of government in the performance of their functions, and by employees of the General Secretariat in the performance of their tasks and responsibilities.
56 . Rule 69 provides that material from government sessions, official decisions adopted by the government, minutes and audio-recordings are kept in the official records of the General Secretariat and may be used with the consent of the Secretary General of the government. Classified material are stored and used in accordance with specific regulations.
57 . Rule 71 provides that the material considered by the government at sessions shall be published on the government’s web portal, in accordance with an official decision of the government. The government notifies the public about its work by holding press conferences with the Prime Minister and members of government, by issuing press releases, and in other appropriate ways. Press releases from a government session are given by the Deputy Prime Ministers and ministers designated by the Prime Minister, as well as by the Public Relations Bureau of the General Secretariat.
58 . The first paragraph of rule 9 of the Rules on the Web Portal and Sub-Portals of the Government of Montenegro provides that the government’s web portal is available to users seven days a week, 24 hours a day.
59 . The Decision on the Publication of Material from Government Sessions determines which types of material from government sessions are published on the government’s web portal and prescribes the manner and procedure for the publication of such material.
60 . Section 2 provides that within the meaning of this Decision, material consists of (1) a draft agenda of a government session; (2) material examined by the government at a session which has not been made classified (draft Acts, bills, reports on a public debate; proposals of decrees, decisions, strategies, plans, reports and information; drafts or proposals of agreements; proposals of decisions on appointments, nominations or discharge from office); and (3) verified conclusions of the government adopted in connection with the examined material which has been published.
61 . The first paragraph of section 7 provides that a draft agenda, material for a corresponding agenda item, a verified conclusion of the government, and consolidated texts of the material referred to in point 2 of section 2 above shall be published on the government’s web portal immediately once received by the web portal administrator from the government’s Public Relations Bureau.
62 . On 21 November 2019 and 13 February 2020 respectively the Administrative Court quashed a decision of the Directorate for the Protection of Classified Information ( Direkcija za zaštitu tajnih podataka ) and a decision of the Ministry of Finance refusing other requests which the applicant organisation had made for access to information which was classified as “internal”. The court held, in substance, that simply referring to information as “internal” was not sufficient to restrict access to information. In particular, it was unclear how the requested information related to section 14, especially since the classification “internal” protected the functioning of a certain body, which had not been provided for under section 14 of the FAIA. In addition, the court examined the official decisions to classify certain information and found that they had not been adopted in accordance with the second paragraph of section 10 of the Classified Information Act, and that in particular, no reasons had been given in relation to how disclosure of the requested information would cause harmful consequences for the functioning of the bodies in question.
63 The Council of Europe Convention on Access to Official Documents (CETS No. 205), also known as the Tromsø Convention, entered into force on 1 December 2020. Montenegro is one of its 17 Parties. Article 3 of that Convention sets out possible limitations to access to official documents. In particular, the first paragraph of Article 3 provides that each Party may limit the right of access to official documents, and that limitations shall be set down precisely in law, be necessary in a democratic society and be proportionate to the aim of protecting specific interests listed in its sub-paragraphs, including pursuant to sub-paragraph k) the deliberations within or between public authorities concerning the examination of a matter. Paragraph 34 of the explanatory report to the Tromsø Convention provides that the purpose of that limitation is to preserve the quality of the decision-making process by allowing a certain free “space to think”.
64 The Council of Europe Access Info Group (AIG) is one of the two bodies of the Tromsø Convention monitoring system. In July 2024 the AIG published a Baseline Evaluation Report on the implementation of the Tromsø Convention in respect of Montenegro. The report noted that the interests provided for in section 14(4) of the FAIA corresponded, inter alia , to the legitimate aims provided for in Article 3 § 1 (k) of that Convention; that section 16 of the FAIA mirrored to a large extent the harm test required under Article 3 § 2 of the Convention; and that section 17 of the FAIA was in line with Article 3 § 2 of the Convention.
65 The AIG Opinion on the definition of “official documents” according to the Tromsø Convention, adopted on 5 November 2025, provides that the legitimate interest in preserving the quality of the decision-making process by allowing a certain free “space to think” for public officials and in protecting the confidentiality of proceedings within and between public authorities is recognised as a ground for limiting the right of access under Article 3 § 1 (k) of the Convention (see paragraph 21 of the Opinion). It further provides that the very existence of this exception in sub-paragraph k shows that the Convention does not intend to exclude from its scope documents that were prepared in the course of decision-making, deliberations or inter-institutional consultations, once they have been completed for their internal purpose (ibid.).
66 The applicant organisation complained under Article 10 of the Convention that the refusal of its request had been in breach of its right of free access to information, that the domestic bodies had not properly examined its request, and that the relevant decisions had lacked adequate reasoning.
67 Article 10 reads as follows:
“1. Everyone has the right to freedom of expression. This right shall include freedom to hold opinions and to receive and impart information and ideas without interference by public authority and regardless of frontiers. This Article shall not prevent States from requiring the licensing of broadcasting, television or cinema enterprises.
2 The exercise of these freedoms, since it carries with it duties and responsibilities, may be subject to such formalities, conditions, restrictions or penalties as are prescribed by law and are necessary in a democratic society, in the interests of national security, territorial integrity or public safety, for the prevention of disorder or crime, for the protection of health or morals, for the protection of the reputation or rights of others, for preventing the disclosure of information received in confidence, or for maintaining the authority and impartiality of the judiciary.”
68 The Government submitted that the application was incompatible ratione materiae , as the applicant organisation had not specified the purpose of its request for information and had not argued that it wanted to contribute to some debate of public interest or to impart that information, all of which distinguished the case at hand from Magyar Helsinki Bizottság v. Hungary [GC] (no. 18030/11, 8 November 2016), Társaság a Szabadságjogokért v. Hungary (no. 37374/05, 14 April 2009), and Zöldi v. Hungary (no. 49049/18, 4 April 2024). They also maintained that the applicant organisation had not proved that it had needed the audio-recording in question for some of its activities or in order to exercise its rights under Article 10 of the Convention, nor had it argued that the requested information indicated that some of the circumstances under section 17 of FAIA existed (see paragraph 36 above). The Government further submitted that the nature of the information was such that the relevant statute had specified that it could be exempted from publication, and the applicant organisation had not even attempted to prove that there was any overriding public interest in publishing that information.
69 The Government submitted that only in its application to the Court had the applicant organisation submitted for the first time that citizens had been deprived of their right to know about the precise positions of the executive authorities on specific topics, and that in the session in question the Minister of Transport had given oral information about rights over real estate being transferred from municipalities to the State, for which there had been no other written data. The Government submitted that it was not sufficient for the applicant organisation to raise that before the Court without raising it before the relevant domestic bodies, and that in not doing so, the applicant organisation had failed to allow the domestic authorities to perform the necessary balancing exercise.
70 . The Government further maintained that the proposed agendas for government sessions and all the material examined, decisions adopted and conclusions verified by the government at those sessions were immediately published on the government’s website (see paragraph 61 above), which ensured that the public was aware of all the information needed in order to exercise democratic control, in compliance with section 5 of the FAIA (see paragraph 30 above). The Government submitted that the government was a collective body and decisions were made by majority vote (see paragraph 51 above), and that the Minister of Transport’s oral information had merely been presented during the session, but not adopted. The Government further submitted that the applicant organisation could also have requested access to the minutes of the session in question, which contained the names of all those who had been present and absent and information on what the government had decided in relation to each and every point on its agenda (see paragraph 54 above). They referred to section 2 and the first paragraph of section 7 of the Decision on the Publication of Material from Sessions of the Government, and rules 63 and 71 of the Government Rules of Procedure (see paragraphs 60-61, 54 and 57 above).
71 The Government disagreed that the relevant review should have been conducted after the request for access to information had been submitted, and referred to the third paragraph of section 10 of the Classified Information Act (see paragraphs 42 above). They maintained that the relevant bodies and the courts had carefully examined the matter and had given clear reasons why the audio-recordings had been classified as confidential, which could not be considered arbitrary. They also referred in detail to the reasoning of the Prime Minister’s decision to declare audio-recordings of government sessions confidential (see paragraph 10 above).
72 The Government concluded by submitting that in refusing the applicant organisation’s request, the domestic bodies had in no way breached its freedom of expression, and that there had been no interference with the applicant organisation’s rights under Article 10; they also referred, inter alia , to Saure v. Germany ((dec.), no. 6106/16, 19 October 2021).
73 . The applicant organisation submitted that requiring it to justify its interest in the information in question was unlawful, as it was contrary to section 3 of the FAIA (see paragraph 29 above). It also submitted that depriving it of the requested information had deprived the public of the right to know what positions members of government had adopted in respect of the topics on the agenda. The applicant organisation considered that at least in respect of bills and decrees, there could be no interest in protecting monetary, economic or foreign policy which would justify a complete restriction of access to information. Lastly, on the day of the session in question oral information about the transfer of rights over certain real estate had been on the agenda; there had been no other written or available information about that matter except for the audio-recording of the session, even though it had related to one of the most important infrastructure projects in Montenegro and had involved enormous loans taken out by the State and numerous delays to the works in question. The applicant organisation further submitted that it was not clear from the impugned decisions how that information could jeopardise the economic, monetary or foreign policy of Montenegro. If the audio-recording had been disclosed then the public would have been made aware of at least some of the government’s work and its approach to key pieces of legislation and projects in the country.
74 The applicant organisation also maintained that the domestic decisions had been made without examining the agenda for the government session on the relevant day and out of context. It also argued that the domestic bodies had failed to examine whether the information had been properly classified, if the confidential status of the information had been limited in time and, if so, whether it could be declassified. The applicant organisation referred to the second paragraph of section 44 of the FAIA, two other rulings of the Administrative Court (see paragraph 38 and 62 above), and section 18 of the Classified Information Act (see paragraph 45 above). It also argued that the Government Rules of Procedure could not be an obstacle to access to information.
75 The applicant organisation maintained that in any event, the confidentiality of an entire audio-recording of a government session could not be justified by a single and general explanation, and that at least part of such a recording had to be disclosed. It also submitted that a general explanation ( paušalno obrazloženje ) about the confidentiality of information which was provided in advance, where there was no specific reason or basis for such confidentiality, was an example of arbitrariness and a lack of transparency, and that all requests for free access to such information would be destined to fail in those circumstances. The applicant organisation submitted that every audio-recording should be examined individually in order to determine whether there were reasons for the entire recording or part of it being subject to some level of confidentiality.
76 . The applicant organisation submitted that the Constitutional Court had wrongly interpreted the relevant statutory provisions, and that its conclusions had been contradictory. More specifically, it maintained that the court had concluded that the public interest in a matter should be examined every time access to information was requested, and at the same time had found that the relevant review had been conducted by the Commission on 28 December 2016, that is, before the relevant information had come into existence. That in itself offered no guarantees that the public interest in the matter in question had indeed been examined after the request for free access to information had been lodged.
77 . In its observations, the applicant organisation emphasised its role as a public watchdog – a role which, it submitted, had not been disputed by the courts. It reiterated that it collected, analysed and compared information, and thus reached conclusions on important questions for the public and on potential abuses and responsibilities. The results of its research depended on the material collected. The applicant organisation informed the public of its conclusions by means of notices ( obavještenja ), procedures, documentaries, publications and other appropriate methods. It maintained that it was common knowledge that that was its way of working, and that the government’s insistence that it had been the applicant organisation’s duty to explain why it was seeking the information and how it intended to use that information had actually undermined the rights that the organisation, as a public watchdog, had and should have.
78 . The applicant organisation submitted that the relevant bodies had neither applied the relevant provisions properly nor examined the facts and arguments that it had referred to or of which they themselves had been aware; the failure to examine those facts and arguments had clearly indicated that the public interest in disclosure had not been sufficiently examined.
79 The applicant organisation considered that the reason for its interest in the requested information, including the purpose of its request, had been clear from the wording of its request, especially bearing in mind the indisputable importance to the public of any of the topics in question. In any event, the request had referred to information of obvious social importance.
80 . The applicant organisation also submitted that the present case could be distinguished from Saure v. Germany (no. 2) (no. 6091/16, 28 March 2023), as the information in that case had concerned national security and the applicant in the case had actually received some information unlike the applicant organisation in the present case.
81 . The relevant principles to be applied in assessing whether the denial of access to information constitutes an interference with freedom of expression have been set out in Magyar Helsinki Bizottság , cited above, §§ 149-70). In particular, Article 10 does not confer on the individual a right of access to information held by a public authority, nor oblige the Government to impart such information to an individual. Nevertheless, such a right or obligation may arise, firstly, where disclosure of the information has been imposed by a judicial order which has gained legal force (which is not an issue in the present case) and, secondly, in circumstances where access to the information is instrumental for the individual’s exercise of his or her right to freedom of expression, in particular “the freedom to receive and impart information”, and where its denial constitutes an interference with that right (ibid., § 156) . Whether and to what extent the denial of access to information constitutes an interference with an applicant’s freedom ‑ of ‑ expression rights must be assessed in each individual case and in the light of its particular circumstances (ibid., § 157). In order to determine whether Article 10 can be said to apply to a public authority’s refusal to disclose information, the situation must be assessed in the light of the following criteria: (a) the purpose of the information request; (b) the nature of the information sought; (c) the particular role of the seeker of the information in “receiving and imparting” it to the public; and (d) whether the information was ready and available (ibid., §§ 158 ‑ 70).
82 The Court notes at the outset that it is not its role to pronounce itself in general on whether audio recordings of Government sessions should be public or non-public for the purposes of the domestic law, and the contracting States enjoy a wide margin of discretion in this respect (see, mutatis mutandis , Sieć Obywatelska Watchdog Polska v. Poland , no. 10103/20, § 63, 21 March 2024).
83 Starting with the last of the above-mentioned criteria (see Centre for Democracy and the Rule of Law v. Ukraine (dec.), no. 75865/11, § 50, 3 March 2020), the Court notes that it is not in dispute that the information which the applicant organisation sought was ready and available (see also paragraph 56 above).
84 In assessing whether the respondent State interfered with the applicant organisation’s Article 10 rights by denying it access to certain documents, the Court has attached particular weight to the applicant’s role as a journalist, social watchdog or NGO whose activities related to matters of public interest (see Sieć Obywatelska Watchdog Polska , cited above, § 54, and the authorities cited therein). The Court has accepted that when an NGO draws attention to matters of public interest, it is exercising a public watchdog role of similar importance to that of the press and may be characterised as a social “watchdog” warranting similar protection under the Convention to that afforded to the press (ibid., § 55; see, also, Magyar Helsinki Bizottság , cited above, § 166). It has recognised that civil society makes an important contribution to the discussion of public affairs (ibid.).
85 The Court notes that the applicant organisation is a well ‑ established NGO that investigates corruption and organised crime (see paragraph 3 above), and that the Constitutional Court acknowledged that it could have the role of a public watchdog (see paragraph 21 above), which was not disputed by the Government. The extent to which the applicant organisation explained the link between the exercise of its watchdog function and the information it sought from the government relates to the question of the “purpose of the information request” and will be examined below (see Centre for Democracy and the Rule of Law (dec.), cited above, § 51).
86 The Court has to examine whether the information to which access was sought satisfied the public-interest test which, according to its general definition, exists where disclosure provides transparency on the manner of conduct of public affairs and on matters of interest for society as a whole, and thereby allows participation in public governance by the general public. What might constitute a subject of public interest will depend on the circumstances of each case (see, for instance, Magyar Helsinki Bizottság , cited above, § 162).
87 The Court does not exclude that, depending on the circumstances, disclosing audio-recordings of government sessions or part of it may be of a public interest. In the circumstances of the present case, the Court notes that the audio-recording sought by the applicant organisation had been classified as confidential and that the organisation did not indicate, either in its request or thereafter in the domestic proceedings, any overriding public interest in disclosing the entire audio-recording or part of it. Nor did the applicant organisation indicate that there was a public debate on a particular question of public interest and that it needed the information in question to participate in the debate (see paragraphs 12, 14-15, 17 and 19 above). As set out in more detail below, the applicant organisation made only general submissions that the public interest in disclosure was indisputable, as such recordings contained information about how decisions on questions relevant to all citizens were examined and adopted (see paragraph 93 below).
88 The applicant organisation did not contest that all other material related to government sessions – including agendas, material which had been examined, and adopted decisions and conclusions – was duly published and available online, save for material which was confidential (see paragraphs 60-61 above). The applicant organisation itself submitted a press release from the session in question which it had found online (see paragraph 11 above). It did not contest either the availability and/or accuracy of such information, nor did it argue that any of the documents adopted during the session in question had not been published because they had been classified. The only unavailable information was the audio-recording of the discussion during the session, which included the oral information provided by the Minister of Transport concerning the transfer of certain real estate from municipalities to the State. The Court considers that the applicant organisation thus had access to plenty of information related to government sessions, and could therefore proceed with any activity that it might have been conducting at the time (compare Studio Monitori and Others v. Georgia , nos. 44920/09 and 8942/10, § 41, 30 January 2020). The Court also finds that, in the circumstances of the present case, the applicant organisation failed to show that there has been a public-interest in disclosing the requested information.
89 . The Court is not called upon to examine whether, as a matter of principle, documents of the type requested by the applicant organisation could or should have been disclosed. Rather, it should establish if, at any stage of the proceedings, the applicant organisation showed that the purpose of its information request was to enable it to effectively exercise its freedom of expression, and that access to the information requested was instrumental for the exercise of the right conferred by Article 10 § 1.
90 . The Court reiterates that it is not sufficient that an applicant make an abstract point to the effect that certain information should be made accessible as a matter of the general principle of transparency (ibid., § 54). In another case, the Court found that an applicant association’s statement that the information sought was of public interest had been too general and that the applicant association had failed to clarify why, despite some information having been made available, the information sought could be of interest to society as a whole (see Georgian Young Lawyers’ Association v. Georgia (dec.), no. 2703/12, §§ 30-33, 19 January 2021). The Court relied on similar considerations in Studio Monitori and Others , cited above, §§ 40-42; Mikiashvili and Others v. Georgia ((dec.), nos. 18865/11 and 51865/11, § 53, 19 January 2021); and Namazli v. Azerbaijan ((dec.), no. 28203/10, §§ 36-37 and 39, 7 June 2022).
91 . The Court also reiterates that for this criterion to be satisfied, it would not be sufficient for an applicant to explain that purpose for the first time in the proceedings before the Court. While it is noted that the relevant domestic legislation does not require that the reasons for requesting information be stated, the Court reiterates that stating the reasons for requesting the information is one of the Court’s criteria in order to determine whether Article 10 can be said to apply to a public authority’s refusal to disclose information or not (see paragraph 78 above). A statement of purpose is therefore an inevitable precondition for applying the test of lawfulness and balancing the confidentiality of information against an overriding public interest in its disclosure. It is therefore in the first place before the relevant domestic authorities that the seeker of information must sufficiently explain the exact purpose of the request by specifying, inter alia , how his or her particular role in receiving and imparting information to the public is compatible with the nature of the information sought, and why access to it is instrumental for the exercise of his or her right to freedom of expression (see Mikiashvili and Others , cited above, § 50, with further references).
92 . The Court notes that whilst the applicant organisation’s role was undeniably compatible with the scope of the right to solicit access to State ‑ held information (see Magyar Helsinki Bizottság , cited above, § 166), it is unclear what the purpose of its request was, especially given the diverse range of topics which were on the agenda of the government session on that particular day (see paragraph 11 above). In particular, the applicant organisation failed to specify, in the relevant domestic proceedings, the purpose of its request for a copy of the particular audio-recording and why it was necessary for the exercise of its freedom to receive and impart information to others (see paragraph 12 above; contrast Cangı v. Turke y , no. 24973/15, § 32, 29 January 2019).
93 . The applicant organisation also failed to remedy its initial omission in the subsequent judicial proceedings (see paragraphs 14-15, 17 and 19 above; compare Studio Monitori and Others , cited above, § 40; and contrast Mikiashvili and Others , cited above, § 51, and Centre for Democracy and the Rule of Law v. Ukraine , no. 10090/16, § 97, 26 March 2020, where the applicants in both cases remedied their initial omissions to give reasons for their requests in the subsequent judicial proceedings). The applicant organisation limited itself to submitting, in substance, that the public interest in disclosure was indisputable, as such recordings contained information about how decisions on questions relevant to all citizens were examined and adopted; that declaring all audio-recordings of government sessions confidential could only be in the interest of covering up corruption and abuses; and that in being denied access to the requested information, the applicant organisation had been deprived of its right to impart information (see paragraphs 14-15 and 19 above). The Court considers that such submissions were too general and abstract, and that the applicant organisation thus failed to specify why the requested audio-recording could be of interest to society as a whole (see paragraph 90 above).
94 The Court also observes that it was only in its application and observations that the applicant organisation emphasised its role as a public watchdog and referred to its general working methods (see paragraph 77 above). Only then did it submit, in particular, that the requested information had contained oral information provided by the Minister of Transport about which there was no other written or available information, and that that oral information had directly affected the budget (see paragraphs 73 and 80 in fine above). Quite apart from whether those submissions would have been sufficient, the Court notes that for this criterion to be satisfied, it would not be sufficient for an applicant to explain the purpose of such a request for the first time in the proceedings before the Court (see paragraph 91 above).
95 Having regard to the above considerations, the Court finds that it cannot be established, in view of all the publicly available material related to government sessions, that access to the information sought was instrumental for the exercise of the applicant organisation’s right to freedom of expression and that its denial constituted an interference with that right (compare Namazli (dec.), cited above, § 39). It follows that Article 10 does not apply and that the application is incompatible ratione materiae with the provisions of the Convention within the meaning of Article 35 § 3 (a) and must be rejected in accordance with Article 35 § 4.
For these reasons, the Court, unanimously,
Declares the application inadmissible.
Done in English and notified in writing on 19 November 2026.
Ilse Freiwirth Erik Wennerström Registrar President
[1] Available at www.mans.co.me/en/, last accessed on 9 September 2026.