Berlizeva and Others v. Russia
Struck out of the list
Berörda konventionsartiklar
FIRST SECTION
Application no. 50437/06 by Natalya Vladimirovna BERLIZEVA and Others and 20 other “Yakut pensioners” cases against Russia
The European Court of Human Rights (First Section), sitting on 12 November 2009 as a Chamber composed of:
Christos Rozakis, President, Nina Vajić, Anatoly Kovler, Dean Spielmann, Sverre Erik Jebens, Giorgio Malinverni, George Nicolaou, judges, and Søren Nielsen, Section Registrar ,
Having regard to the above applications,
Having deliberated, decides as follows:
THE FACTS
The applicants are 63 Russian nationals whose names and dates of birth are tabulated in the Annex. They were represented before the Court by Mr I. Novikov, a lawyer practising in Novosibirsk. The Russian Government (“the Government”) were represented by Ms V. Milinchuk and Mr G. Matyushkin, former and present Representatives of the Russian Federation at the European Court of Human Rights.
The facts of the case, as submitted by the parties, may be summarised as follows.
The applicants, old-age pensioners from Yakutia, sued a pension authority for miscalculating their pensions. Binding judgments passed in their favour were quashed on supervisory review because of misinterpretation of material law.
COMPLAINT
The applicants complained under Articles 6 and 13 of the Convention, and Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 about the quashing of the judgments.
THE LAW
In view of the similarity of the applications, the Court finds it appropriate to join them.
The Court sent the Government’s observations to Mr Novikov and requested him to submit in reply any observations together with any claims for just satisfaction.
Not having received the observations in time, the Court warned Mr Novikov by registered post that under Article 37 § 1 (a) of the Convention it might strike the applications out of its list of cases if the circumstances led to the conclusion that the applicants did not intend to pursue the applications. Mr Novikov received these warnings, but no response of his has reached the Court.
The dates of respective letters are shown in the Annex.
The Court considers that, in these circumstances, the applicants may be regarded as no longer wishing to pursue their application, within the meaning of Article 37 § 1 (a) of the Convention. Furthermore, in accordance with Article 37 § 1 in fine , the Court finds no special circumstances regarding respect for human rights as defined in the Convention and its Protocols which require the continued examination of the cases. In view of the above, it is appropriate to strike the cases out of the list.
For these reasons, the Court unanimously
Decides to join the applications and strike them out of its list of cases.
Søren Nielsen Christos Rozakis Registrar President
ANNEX
Application no.
Introduced on
Applicant
Born in
Observations requested on
Observations due by
Warning sent on
Warning received on
50437/06
28/10/06
Berzliyeva Natalya Vladimirovna
1954
07/04/08
09/06/08
26/08/08
04/09/08
Zebolov Nikolay Mikhaylovich
1949
Krishtapovich Ludmila Borisovna
1944
Novikova Vera Ilyinichna
1932
Peresypkin Viktor Vasilyevich
1958
Polupoltinnykh Nina Ivanovna
1954
50978/06
08/11/06
Romanenko Yuriy Mikhaylovich
1950
07/04/08
09/06/08
26/08/08
04/09/08
Plaksina Olga Ivanovna
1949
Ovechkina Galina Konstantinovna
1950
2584/07
16/12/06
Shirshova Tamara Mikhaylovna
1938
11/09/08
13/11/08
20/02/09
04/03/09
2589/07
16/12/06
Levin Ivan Grigoryevich
1949
11/09/08
13/11/08
20/02/09
04/03/09
Kiseleva Tatyana Vasilyevna
1952
Gazimullin Faiz Sharifulinovich
1948
2595/07
16/12/06
Nalimova Tatyana Petrovna
1954
11/09/08
13/11/08
20/02/09
04/03/09
2600/07
02/12/06
Sinelnikov Veniamin Petrovich
1940
11/09/08
13/11/08
20/02/09
04/03/09
Popov Sergey Nikolayevich
1955
2606/07
02/12/06
Nikitina Valentina Leontyevna
1948
11/09/08
13/11/08
20/02/09
04/03/09
Nikitin Yuriy Nikolayevich
1947
2629/07
02/12/06
Taganashkina Emma Davydovna
1940
11/09/08
13/11/08
20/02/09
04/03/09
2632/07
02/12/06
Kashina Galina Ivanovna
1954
11/09/08
13/11/08
20/02/09
04/03/09
2635/07
02/12/06
Agekyan Valentina Petrovna
1957
11/09/08
13/11/08
20/02/09
04/03/09
Yeshkina Galina Semyonovna
1955
Yeshkin Aleksandr Grigoryevich
1953
2637/07
02/12/06
Nurgaliyeva Olga Semyonovna
1950
08/10/08
20/11/08
20/02/09
04/03/09
2640/07
15/10/06
Lukyanova Yelena Andreyevna
1946
08/10/08
20/11/08
20/02/09
04/03/09
2642/07
23/11/06
Shubenko Olga Mikhaylovna
1954
08/10/08
20/11/08
20/02/09
04/03/09
2646/07
23/11/06
Kashina Tatyana Nikolayevna
1958
08/10/08
20/11/08
20/02/09
04/03/09
Kostornaya Nadezhda Georgiyevna
1951
Netronova Valentina Grigoryevna
1939
Nurgaliyev Georgiy Mubarakovich
1952
Popova Valentina Dmitriyevna
1949
Titova Natalya Aleksandrovna
1950
3027/07
15/10/06
Borisenko Olga Valentinovna
1954
06/02/09
10/04/09
13/07/09
04/08/09
Smirnova Olga Mikhaylovna
1954
Savko Ivan Mikhaylovich
1947
Demenchuk Nikolay Vasilyevich
1950
Krysov Fedor Markovich
1956
3036/07
23/11/06
Bogatyreva Lidiya Fedorovna
1954
04/02/09
08/04/09
13/07/09
04/08/09
Golovchenko Oleg Ivanovich
1952
Zaytseva Svetlana Valentinovna
1954
Kalashnikova Galina Kuzminichna
1954
Kudryavtseva Ludmila Ivanovna
1954
Levchenko Lubov Nikolayevna
1956
Salimova Farzana Farrakhovna
1954
Ukolov Valentin Mikhaylovich
1949
Yagudina Tatyana Ivanovna
1958
3038/07
02/12/06
Denisova Olga Petrovna
1959
04/02/09
08/04/09
13/07/09
04/08/09
Agarkov Aleksey Alekseyevich
1954
Kuznetsova Raissa Pavlovna
1952
Kiselev Vladimir Vasilyevich
1953
Chulykov Nikolay Nikitovich
1954
Timurkhanova Munira Gabdimalikovna
1954
3347/07
08/11/06
Nikitina Vera Sergeyevna
1950
07/04/08
09/06/08
26/08/08
04/09/08
Pilnova Nina Ivanovna
1946
Skobeyeva Lubov Adamovna
1946
Sokolnikova Tatyana Aleksandrovna
1949
Sokolnikov Aleksey Petrovich
1947
4581/07
01/12/06
Gordiyenko Natalya Yakovlevna
1954
07/04/08
09/06/08
26/08/08
04/09/08
Tergyuleva Yevguenia Yeremeyevna
1954
8551/07
15/01/07
Osadchaya Raisa Yakovlevna
1937
04/02/09
08/04/09
13/07/09
04/08/09
Osadchiy Anatoliy Ilyich
1935
5428/07
19/12/06
Klepko Aleksandr Nikolayevich
1953
13/02/09
17/04/09
13/07/09
04/08/09