lagen.nu
T-98/25

Judgment of the General Court (Tenth Chamber) 4 November 2026

CELEX
62025TJ0098
Datum
2026-11-04
Källa
eur-lex.europa.eu

JUDGMENT OF THE GENERAL COURT (Tenth Chamber)

4 November 2026 ( * )

( Energy – Connecting Europe Facility – Regulation (EU, Euratom) No 347/2013 – Calls for proposals – Cross-border energy infrastructure projects – Proposal for the construction of a pipeline in the eastern Mediterranean Sea – Rejection of the proposal as inadmissible – Obligation to state reasons – Error of assessment – Right to be heard – Liability )

In Case T‑98/25,

Ypothalassios Agogos Fysikou Aeriou Elladas – Italias – Poseidon AE (YAFA Poseidon), established in Athens (Greece), represented by C. Cocuzza, F. Francica, T. Mambrini and C. Pasina, lawyers,

applicant,

v

European Climate, Infrastructure and Environment Executive Agency (CINEA), represented by I. Ramallo García-Pérez, N. Kopietz and V. Bard, acting as Agents, and by M. Troncoso Ferrer and L. Lence de Frutos, lawyers,

defendant,

THE GENERAL COURT (Tenth Chamber),

composed of S.L. Kalėda (Rapporteur), President, H. Kanninen and T. Perišin, Judges,

Registrar: S. Spyropoulos, Administrator,

having regard to the written part of the procedure,

further to the hearing on 21 April 2026,

gives the following

Judgment

1 By its action under Article 263 TFEU, the applicant, Ypothalassios Agogos Fysikou Aeriou Elladas – Italias – Poseidon AE (YAFA Poseidon), seeks, first, annulment of Decision Ares(2024) 8655163 of the European Climate, Infrastructure and Environment Executive Agency (CINEA) of 4 December 2024, by which CINEA rejected its proposal relating to the Connecting Europe Facility (CEF) (‘the contested decision’), and, second, compensation for the damage which it claims to have suffered as a result of the loss of an opportunity to be granted funds following the award procedure.

Background to the dispute

2 On 11 April 2024, CINEA launched a call for proposals ‘CEF 2 Energy – Projects of Common and Mutual Interest 2024’, bearing the reference CEF-E-2024-PCI-PMI (‘the call for proposals’). The objective of the call for proposals was to finance, under the CEF, studies or works contributing to the preparation of energy infrastructure for projects of common interest (‘PCIs’) and projects of mutual interest (‘PMIs’) which have significant socioeconomic benefits and ensure greater solidarity between Member States, but which do not receive adequate market financing. The closing date for the submission of proposals was set at 22 October 2024.

3 Paragraph 5 of the call for proposals, entitled ‘Admissibility and documents’, provided that ‘proposals [had to] be complete and contain all the requested information and all required annexes and supporting documents’, namely ‘Application Form Part A – contains administrative information about the participants … Application Form Part B – contains the technical description of the project … Mandatory annexes and supporting documents … Detailed budget table per [work package] – Annual activity reports … – Timetable … – Agreement by the concerned Member States (Letter of support) – Environmental compliance file – List of previous projects (key projects for the last 4 years) – … compliance form …’.

4 In addition, according to paragraph 5 of the call for proposals, for PCIs and PMIs falling within the categories referred to in Article 24 of Regulation (EU) 2022/869 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 30 May 2022 on guidelines for trans-European energy infrastructure, amending Regulations (EC) No 715/2009, (EU) 2019/942 and (EU) 2019/943 and Directives 2009/73/EC and (EU) 2019/944, and repealing Regulation (EU) No 347/2013 (OJ 2022 L 152, p. 45; ‘the 2022 TEN-E Regulation’), and in point 1(a) to (d) and (f) and point 3 of Annex II to that regulation, the following documents had to be submitted: first, a full project-specific cost-benefit analysis; second, a project-specific and legally valid cross-border cost allocation (CBCA) decision (‘the CBCA decision’), which, according to footnote 8 to the call for proposals, had to ‘be fully compliant with the requirements of Article 16 of the [2022] TEN-E Regulation and [had to] be still in force (i.e., not expired, cancelled or with ongoing appeals) and display evidence of consultation with other concerned Transmission System Operators and National Regulatory Authorities’, ‘applicants [taking into account] as appropriate the CBCA guidance that is already available, for instance the … Recommendation No 02/2023 [of the Agency for the Cooperation of Energy Regulators (ACER)] of 22 June 2023 on good practices for the treatment of the investment requests, including [CBCA] requests for PCIs …’; third, a ‘business plan and other assessments showing that the project cannot be financed by the market or through the regulatory framework’.

5 The pipeline project known as ‘EastMed’, which aims to connect Cyprus to the European gas network (‘the EastMed project’), is included in the EU list of PCIs, in accordance with the provisions of Regulation (EU) No 347/2013 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 17 April 2013 on guidelines for trans-European energy infrastructure and repealing Decision No 1364/2006/EC and amending Regulations (EC) No 713/2009, (EC) No 714/2009 and (EC) No 715/2009 (OJ 2013 L 115, p. 39; ‘the 2013 TEN-E Regulation’) and the 2022 TEN-E Regulation.

6 On 22 October 2024, the applicant submitted a proposal for financial support under the call for proposals (‘the proposal at issue’) relating to the EastMed project.

7 With its proposal, the applicant attached, as the CBCA decision, a document entitled ‘Coordinated decision on EastMed PCI Investment Request and on the [CBCA] by the Hellenic Regulatory Authority for Energy[,] Waste and Water, the Cyprus Energy Regulatory Authority and the Italian Regulatory Authority for Energy, [N]etworks and Environment’, signed by the national regulatory authorities (‘the NRAs’) concerned (‘the NRA decision’).

8 On 9 December 2024, by the contested decision, CINEA rejected the proposal at issue on the ground that it did not comply with the conditions of admissibility.

9 The contested decision states:

‘The proposal is inadmissible, as it is incomplete. The applicants submitted a document entitled “Coordinated decision on EastMed PCI Investment Request and on the [CBCA] by the Hellenic Regulatory Authority for Energy[,] Waste and Water, the Cyprus Energy Regulatory Authority and the Italian Regulatory Authority for Energy, [N]etworks and Environment”. The document was issued in October 2024 pursuant to [the 2013 TEN-E Regulation] applicable as regards the project at the time. Upon examination of this document, it has been found not to be in compliance with the requirements of Article 12 of [the 2013 TEN-E Regulation], since (i) no request for investment is addressed at least to the regulatory systems of the constructing countries, (ii) the principle of Union grants as last resort is not reflected, (iii) there is no clarity on the regulatory nature of the project leaving doubts whether the project would be eligible or not for such a decision, in particular, as regards tariff regulation, and (iv) the benefits of the project per Member State do not reflect its status under Article 24 of [the 2022 TEN-E Regulation], i.e. to secure the permanent connection of Cyprus to the trans-European gas market. Therefore, the proposal is considered incomplete and inadmissible because the document submitted is not compliant with the call requirements’.

Forms of order sought

10 The applicant claims that the Court should:

– annul the contested decision;

– order CINEA to admit the applicant to the evaluation and award procedure stage of the call for proposals and evaluate its submission in the light of the information provided therein, including all the facts, documents and evidence that have been clarified, and elaborated on, in the present proceedings;

– in the event that the applicant could not be admitted to the evaluation stage, or in the event that it is admitted and does not obtain financing, order CINEA to pay damages to the applicant for an amount equal to the funding sought in the submission, which was wrongfully denied;

– order CINEA to pay the costs.

11 CINEA contends that the Court should:

– dismiss the action as inadmissible or unfounded;

– order the applicant to pay the costs.

Law

The Court’s jurisdiction with regard to the applicant’s second head of claim

12 By its second head of claim, the applicant asks the Court, in essence, to order CINEA to declare the proposal at issue admissible and to carry out an evaluation of that proposal.

13 CINEA submits that the second head of claim contains a request for the Court to issue directions and must be rejected as inadmissible.

14 In that regard, it is sufficient to recall that, when exercising judicial review of legality under Article 263 TFEU, the Court has no jurisdiction to issue directions to the institutions, bodies, offices and agencies of the European Union (see order of 26 October 1995, Pevasa and Inpesca v Commission , C‑199/94 P and C‑200/94 P, EU:C:1995:360, paragraph 24 and the case-law cited).

15 Accordingly, in so far as the applicant’s second head of claim seeks that the Court issue directions to CINEA, that head of claim must be rejected on the ground of lack of jurisdiction.

The claim for annulment

16 In support of its claim for annulment, the applicant relies on three pleas in law, alleging, in essence, first, infringement of the obligation to state reasons, second, manifest error of assessment and, third, breach of the principle of good administration and of the right to be heard.

The applicable rules

17 As a preliminary point, it must be borne in mind that the 2013 TEN-E Regulation was repealed by the 2022 TEN-E Regulation with effect from 23 June 2022. However, according to Article 32(2) of the 2022 TEN-E Regulation, Articles 2 to 10 and 12 to 14 of, and Annexes I to IV and VI to, the 2013 TEN-E Regulation are to remain in force and produce effects as regards the PCIs included on the fifth Union list until the entry into force of the first Union list of PCIs and PMIs established under the 2022 TEN-E Regulation. The latter list, established by Commission Delegated Regulation (EU) 2024/1041 of 28 November 2023 amending Regulation (EU) 2022/869 of the European Parliament and of the Council as regards the Union list of projects of common interest and projects of mutual interest (OJ L, 2024/1041), entered into force on 28 April 2024.

18 Therefore, when the call for proposals was launched on 11 April 2024, the 2022 TEN-E Regulation and, in particular, Article 12 of the 2013 TEN-E Regulation applied to projects included in the fifth Union list of PCIs established under the 2013 TEN-E Regulation, such as the EastMed project.

19 Thus, paragraph 5 of the call for proposals, under the heading ‘Admissibility and documents’, which lays down the conditions for the admissibility of proposals, refers to the 2022 TEN-E Regulation. (see paragraphs 3 and 4 above).

20 More specifically, paragraph 5 of the call for proposals covers, inter alia, PCIs and PMIs falling within the categories referred to in Article 24 of the 2022 TEN-E Regulation. In that regard, it should be noted that that article lays down the conditions that interconnectors for Cyprus and Malta must fulfil in order to maintain their PCI status under that regulation.

21 In addition, paragraph 5 of the call for proposals refers to Article 16 of the 2022 TEN-E Regulation. In order for a proposal for PCIs falling under the categories referred to in Article 24 of the 2022 TEN-E Regulation to be admissible, footnote 8 to the call for proposals states that that proposal must contain a CBCA decision which must ‘be fully compliant with the requirements of Article 16 of the [2022] TEN-E Regulation’. That article sets out the regulatory requirements that must be fulfilled by a CBCA in order to be admissible under the call for proposals.

22 It should be added that Article 16 of the 2022 TEN-E Regulation defines those regulatory requirements in terms essentially similar to those of Article 12 of the 2013 TEN-E Regulation. As set out in paragraphs 17 and 18 above, when the call for proposals was launched on 11 April 2024, Article 12 of the 2013 TEN-E Regulation, as such, continued to apply to the PCIs included in the fifth Union list, such as the EastMed project.

23 Therefore, the call for proposals, the proposal at issue and the NRA decision provided by the applicant as a CBCA decision must be assessed in the light of all the applicable rules described above, Article 12 of the 2013 TEN-E Regulation in particular.

First plea in law, alleging infringement of the obligation to state reasons

24 According to the applicant, the contested decision does not specify the grounds for the rejection of its proposal as inadmissible. First, while relying on the non-compliance of the NRA decision, it does not set out the regulatory provisions that have not been complied with. None of the four grounds for non-compliance put forward is based on the call for proposals or on the applicable regulatory provisions, which amounts to a total absence of reasons.

25 In that regard, the applicant submits, first of all, that neither the applicable legislation nor the call for proposals requires the NRA decision to address the principle of EU grants as a last resort. The principle relied on by CINEA appears in recitals and recommendations and is not binding. Moreover, the NRA decision specifically addresses the non-viability of the project without CEF financial support, even if no argument on the principle of the use of EU grants as a last resort had to be included in the NRA decision.

26 Second, the applicant claims that the call for proposals and Article 12 of the 2013 TEN-E Regulation do not expressly require NRAs to examine in detail the regulatory nature of the project in general or tariff regulation in particular. In so far as CINEA does not refer in the contested decision to the provisions setting out the obligation of the NRAs to examine in detail the regulatory nature of the project, it failed to fulfil its obligation to state reasons.

27 Third, according to the applicant, neither the call for proposals nor the regulatory provisions require that the proposals highlight, ‘beyond any particular and express threshold’, the benefits under Article 24 of the 2022 TEN-E Regulation in the NRA decision. CINEA did not specify the basis for such a requirement. The applicant submits that the EastMed project was included in the list of PCIs annexed to the 2013 TEN-E Regulation. In any event, the NRA decision and the proposal at issue as a whole do indeed, according to the applicant, address that issue.

28 Lastly, the applicant submits that, at the admissibility stage, CINEA is required only to check whether the candidate has filed the documents required by the call for proposals, without, however, examining the substance of those documents. The reasons given in the contested decision anticipate the assessment of the merits of the proposal, in breach of the call for proposals and Article 12 of the 2013 TEN-E Regulation.

29 In its reply, the applicant criticises CINEA for having identified that the NRA decision was non-compliant, even though the applicant has no control over the content of that decision.

30 CINEA disputes the applicant’s arguments.

31 It is settled case‑law that the statement of reasons required by the second paragraph of Article 296 TFEU must be appropriate to the measure at issue and must disclose in a clear and unequivocal fashion the reasoning followed by the institution which adopted the measure in such a way as to enable the persons concerned to ascertain the reasons for the measure and to enable the court having jurisdiction to exercise its power of review. The requirements to be satisfied by the statement of reasons depend on the circumstances of each case, in particular the content of the measure in question, the nature of the reasons given and the interest which the addressees of the measure, or other parties to whom it is of direct and individual concern, may have in obtaining explanations. It is not necessary for the reasoning to go into all the relevant facts and points of law, since the question whether the statement of reasons meets the requirements of Article 296 TFEU must be assessed with regard not only to its wording but also to its context and to all the legal rules governing the matter in question (see judgment of 9 February 2022, Elevolution – Engenharia v Commission , T‑652/19, not published, EU:T:2022:63, paragraph 46 and the case-law cited).

32 Moreover, where a decision has been adopted in a context with which the person concerned is familiar, it may be reasoned in a summary manner (see judgment of 17 January 2017, Cofely Solelec and Others v Parliament , T‑419/15, not published, EU:T:2017:8, paragraph 61 and the case-law cited).

33 Indeed, it is apparent from the case-law that, where documents relating to the call for tenders or the call for proposals specify and clarify the requirements, a statement of reasons indicating rejection for failure to meet the criteria set out in those documents is regarded as sufficient (see, to that effect, judgments of 9 September 2010, Carpent Languages v Commission , T‑582/08, not published, EU:T:2010:379, paragraphs 42 and 43, and of 10 September 2019, BP v Court of Justice of the European Union , T‑51/18, not published, EU:T:2019:570, paragraph 25).

34 Lastly, it must be borne in mind that the obligation to state reasons in a measure is an essential procedural requirement which must be distinguished from the question whether the reasons given are correct, which goes to the substantive legality of the contested measure. The reasoning of a decision consists in a formal statement of the grounds on which that decision is based. If those grounds are vitiated by errors, those errors will vitiate the substantive legality of the decision, but not the statement of reasons in it, which may be adequate even though it sets out reasons which are incorrect. It follows that the complaints and the arguments seeking to dispute the merits of a measure are irrelevant in the context of a plea alleging lack of or insufficiency of reasoning (judgment of 16 October 2024, Silex v Eismea , T‑654/20, not published, EU:T:2024:702, paragraph 270 and the case-law cited).

35 It is apparent from the grounds of the contested decision, reproduced in paragraph 9 above, that CINEA considered that the proposal at issue was inadmissible because it was incomplete, since the NRA decision, submitted as a project-specific CBCA decision, did not comply with the requirements of Article 12 of the 2013 TEN-E Regulation and Article 24 of the 2022 TEN-E Regulation.

36 The contested decision sets out four grounds of non-compliance of the NRA decision, namely:

‘(i) no request for investment [was] addressed at least to the regulatory systems of the constructing countries, (ii) the principle of Union grants as last resort [was] not reflected, (iii) there [was] no clarity on the regulatory nature of the project leaving doubts whether the project would be eligible or not for such a decision, in particular, as regards tariff regulation, and (iv) the benefits of the project per Member State [did] not reflect its status under Article 24 of [the 2022 TEN-E Regulation], i.e. to secure the permanent connection of Cyprus to the trans-European gas market’.

37 In addition, the statement of reasons for the contested decision must be assessed in the light of the criteria set out in the call for proposals and taking into account the applicable legislation.

38 In that regard, it should be noted that the admissibility requirements of the proposal at issue were clearly set out in paragraph 5 of the call for proposals, entitled ‘Admissibility and documents’, which gave specific information regarding the information and supporting documents that had to be provided with the proposal (see paragraphs 3 and 4 above). Accordingly, it must be borne in mind that, for PCIs and PMIs falling within the categories referred to in Article 24 of the 2022 TEN-E Regulation, sponsors had to provide a project-specific and legally valid CBCA decision, namely that it had to be still in force, fully compliant with the requirements of Article 12 of the 2013 TEN-E Regulation, applicable ratione temporis to the EastMed project, and prepared considering the ACER Recommendations No 5/2015 of 18 December 2015 or No 2/2023 of 22 June 2023, depending on the date on which it was prepared. Furthermore, it is apparent from page 26 of the call for proposals that ‘proposals that do not comply with all the call conditions will be rejected’.

39 It follows that the call for proposals and the rules applicable to it set out clearly and unambiguously the conditions governing the admissibility of a proposal and the consequences of the non-compliance of that proposal with those conditions.

40 Thus, in view of the conditions of admissibility set out in paragraph 38 above, the grounds of the contested decision, while being succinct, make it possible to ascertain clearly and unambiguously the reasons for the rejection of the proposal at issue. It is apparent from those grounds that the proposal at issue was rejected as inadmissible because it was incomplete, since one of the mandatory documents submitted by the applicant, namely the NRA decision, did not, on four specific grounds, comply with the requirements of Article 12 of the 2013 TEN-E Regulation and Article 24 of the 2022 TEN-E Regulation.

41 Furthermore, it should be noted that the contested decision was adopted in a context with which the applicant was familiar.

42 As the parties confirmed at the hearing, prior to the submission of the proposal at issue, on 15 December 2023 and 8 April 2024, CINEA held two meetings with the applicant to discuss the irregularities which CINEA and the European Commission had detected concerning a CBCA decision which the applicant had submitted in a previous CEF call for proposals.

43 It is also apparent from the application that the applicant understood the grounds of the contested decision and was able to defend itself accordingly. Furthermore, since the reasons for the rejection of the proposal at issue were clearly stated in the contested decision, the Court is in a position to assess the merits thereof.

44 Furthermore, the applicant’s claims, set out in the context of the first plea in law (see paragraphs 25 to 29 above), according to which the reasons given in the contested decision are incorrect, which means that they are groundless, are not relevant in the context of a plea alleging lack of or insufficiency of reasoning, in line with the case-law cited in paragraph 34 above. The same applies to the applicant’s arguments alleging that the grounds of the contested decision concern the merits of the proposal at issue and do not concern its admissibility, as well as the fact that it had no control over the content of the NRA decision. Those arguments relate to the merits of the case and will be dealt with in the context of the second plea alleging manifest error of assessment.

45 The first plea in law must therefore be rejected.

Second plea, alleging manifest error of assessment

46 In the first place, according to the applicant, CINEA failed to have regard to the stages of the procedure for evaluating the proposal by carrying out, at the stage of the examination of admissibility, an assessment of the merits of the proposal. It thus exceeded the scope of its duties, which had to be limited to the formal verification of whether the mandatory annexes were complete, without any substantial examination of the content of the proposal or the NRA decision. By challenging the credibility of the data relied upon by the NRAs, CINEA did not limit itself to a review of legal validity, but clearly encroached upon the administrative powers of the national sovereign authorities of three Member States.

47 In the second place, as regards the alleged absence of the investment request within the meaning of Article 12(3) of the 2013 TEN-E Regulation (‘the investment request’), the applicant submits that it submitted such an application to the regulatory systems of the constructing countries. In 2023, the applicant submitted its application for national funding programmes in Italy and Greece. The applicant also submitted a proposal to Greece to supplement the CEF funding in exchange for a transfer of title on one of the onshore sections of the infrastructure, with a view to completing the Greek section of the EastMed project.

48 In addition, the applicant states that the call for proposals contains no indication that an investment request would be incomplete if its text and its practical effects confirmed that no actual costs would be borne by the national regulatory systems. According to the applicant, the legal validity of a CBCA decision depends solely on its compliance with Article 12 of the 2013 TEN-E Regulation, namely that it must be in force, not cancelled or with ongoing appeals, and it must confirm that transmission system operators (‘TSOs’) have been consulted. All those conditions are satisfied in the present case.

49 In the third place, as regards the principle of EU grants as a last resort, the applicant disputes the very existence of a legally binding principle requiring that EU grants may be requested only as a last resort.

50 In the alternative, the applicant submits that, even assuming the existence of such a principle, that principle was complied with in the present case, as the NRA decision established that it was impossible to finance the EastMed project solely by means of transmission tariffs. Furthermore, in so far as it is the European Union as a whole which would derive the most benefits from the EastMed project, requiring the Member States hosting the infrastructure to participate significantly in the EastMed project would constitute a breach of the principle of fairness.

51 In the fourth place, as regards the regulatory nature of the project, the applicant submits that the EastMed project falls within the general regulatory framework applicable to gas infrastructure and that it did not request any derogation in that regard. In those circumstances, it submits that it is subject to all the relevant provisions of EU law, such as those concerning third-party access, tariff regulation and unbundling.

52 In the fifth place, as regards the benefits of the project per Member State, the applicant submits that the call for proposals does not require the NRAs to identify, in their decision, the significant benefits for Cyprus. In any event, the proposal at issue detailed the advantages for that Member State, including, in particular, its permanent integration into the trans-European gas market and the reduction of greenhouse gas emissions.

53 CINEA disputes the applicant’s arguments.

– The extent of the Court’s review

54 It should be noted that, at the stage of assessing the admissibility of the proposals for financial support submitted in response to the call for proposals, CINEA confined itself to verifying compliance with the admissibility conditions, without, however, carrying out an evaluation of the financing proposals. Given that, in the context of that verification, CINEA is not required to carry out an assessment of complex economic and technical issues, the applicant’s second plea alleging a ‘manifest error of assessment’ must be regarded as alleging an error of assessment and subject to full review by the Court.

– The claim that CINEA exceeded the scope of its duties relating to verifying the admissibility of a financing proposal

55 In that connection, it should be noted that the purpose of the 2013 TEN-E Regulation, as explained in Article 1 of that regulation, is, inter alia, to provide rules and guidance for CBCAs and to determine the conditions for eligibility of PCIs for EU financial assistance.

56 Article 12(1) of the 2013 TEN-E Regulation specifies that efficiently incurred investment costs are to be borne by the relevant TSOs or the project promoters of the transmission infrastructure of the Member States to which the project provides a net positive impact, and, to the extent that those costs are not covered by congestion rents or other charges, they are to be paid for by network users through tariffs for network access in that or those Member States. In addition, according to Article 12(3) and (4) of the 2013 TEN-E Regulation, as soon as a project has reached sufficient maturity, the project promoters, after having consulted the TSOs from the Member States which receive a significant net positive impact from it, are to submit an investment request to all the NRAs concerned which, after consulting the project promoters concerned, take coordinated decisions on the allocation of investment costs to be borne by each system operator for the project, as well as their inclusion in tariffs. The NRAs may decide to allocate only part of the costs, or may decide to allocate costs among a package of several PCIs.

57 Furthermore, according to recital 42 of the 2013 TEN-E Regulation, a three-step approach applies to investments in PCIs. First, the market should have the priority to invest. Second, if investments are not made by the market, regulatory solutions should be explored, the relevant regulatory framework should be adjusted if necessary, and the correct application of the relevant regulatory framework should be ensured. Third, where the first two steps are not sufficient to deliver the necessary investments in PCIs, it should be possible to grant EU financial assistance if the PCI fulfils the applicable eligibility criteria.

58 In addition, it should be borne in mind that, according to paragraph 5 of the call for proposals, entitled ‘Admissibility and documents’, financing proposals must include a project-specific and legally valid CBCA decision. In accordance with footnote 8 to that call, such a decision must be fully compliant with the requirements of Article 12 of the 2013 TEN-E Regulation, applicable ratione temporis to the EastMed project, and still in force (that is to say, not expired, cancelled or with ongoing appeals) and display evidence of consultation with other concerned TSOs and NRAs. In addition, applicants must consider, where appropriate, ACER’s recommendations (see paragraph 4 above).

59 In the present case, it should be borne in mind that, in the contested decision, CINEA identified that the NRA decision, submitted in the proposal at issue as a project-specific CBCA decision, did not comply with the requirements of Article 12 of the 2013 TEN-E Regulation and Article 24 of the 2022 TEN-E Regulation.

60 The applicant submits, in essence, that CINEA had to confine itself to the formal verification of the completeness of the proposal, including the mandatory annexes, and that it was not for CINEA, at that stage, to identify the non-compliance of the NRA decision.

61 As regards, in particular, the requirement to submit a project-specific CBCA decision, the call for proposals requires that this decision be legally valid, in line with the requirements of Article 12 of the 2013 TEN-E Regulation, applicable ratione temporis to the EastMed project, and that it display evidence of consultation with other concerned TSOs and NRAs.

62 Contrary to what the applicant argues, it is apparent from the call for proposals that the review of those requirements relates to the admissibility of a proposal. Thus, when reviewing the admissibility of a proposal, CINEA cannot confine itself to verifying whether it contains all the documents required, and it must also ensure that those documents comply with the requirements of the call for proposals. In that regard, contrary to what the applicant claims, by verifying whether the document provided as a project-specific CBCA decision complies with the requirements of Article 12 of the 2013 TEN-E Regulation and Article 24 of the 2022 TEN-E Regulation, CINEA did not exceed its scope of its duties in reviewing the admissibility of a proposal, as provided for in the call for proposals.

63 Moreover, it should be noted that, given the nature of the award criteria provided for in paragraph 9 of the call for proposals – namely the priority and urgency of the action, its maturity, its quality, its impact and the catalytic effect of the EU assistance – the examination of the proposal in the light of those criteria would not allow CINEA to review whether the CBCA decision is compliant with regulatory requirements. Therefore, it is precisely at the stage of examining the admissibility of the proposal that CINEA must ensure that the CBCA decision corresponds to the regulatory requirements stemming, inter alia, from Article 12 of the 2013 TEN-E Regulation.

64 That finding is not called into question by the applicant’s argument that CINEA does not have the power to review the content of the NRA decision, that review being a matter for the competent courts alone. Even though CINEA has no competence to review the legality of that decision or to annul it, it is nevertheless competent to verify whether that document complies with the rules governing the call for proposals, which include Article 12 of the 2013 TEN-E Regulation and Article 24 of the 2022 TEN-E Regulation.

65 Accordingly, the applicant is not justified in claiming that CINEA exceeded the scope of its duty of review at the stage of examining the admissibility of the proposal.

– The first ground of non-compliance, based on the absence of an investment request

66 In that connection, it should be borne in mind that, in the contested decision, CINEA stated that the NRA decision did not comply with the requirements of the applicable provisions, relying on four grounds of non-compliance, namely, first, the absence of an investment request, second, the failure to comply with the principle of EU grants as a last resort, third, the lack of clarity as regards the tariff regulation of the project and, fourth, the lack of details on the advantages per Member State, in particular for Cyprus.

67 As regards the first ground of non-compliance, the applicant disputes CINEA’s conclusion that a proposal must contain an investment request addressed at least to the regulatory systems of the constructing countries.

68 In that regard, it should be borne in mind that Article 12(1) of the 2013 TEN-E Regulation provides that the investment costs are to be borne by the TSOs concerned or by the project promoters and that, to the extent that they are not covered by congestion rents or other charges, they are to be paid for through tariffs for network access in the Member States on which the project has a positive net impact. Thus, the Court considers that that provision governs the order of priority of the sources of financing of the investment costs which, in the first place, must be borne by the TSOs concerned or the project promoters, and which, in the second place, in so far as they are not covered by congestion rents or other charges, must be borne by network users through tariffs for network access. It follows that the award of EU financial assistance is subject to compliance with that order of sources of financing.

69 That interpretation is supported by recital 42 of the 2013 TEN-E Regulation, according to which investments in PCIs should follow a three-step approach, namely, first, the market should have the priority to invest, second, regulatory solutions should be explored and, third, where the first two steps are not sufficient to deliver the necessary investments in PCIs, it should be possible to grant EU financial assistance if the PCI fulfils the applicable eligibility criteria.

70 Next, according to Article 12(3) of the 2013 TEN-E Regulation, project promoters must submit an investment request to all NRAs concerned. In addition, the application must be accompanied by a cost-benefit analysis that complies with the methodology established pursuant to Article 11 of that regulation, a business plan and a CBCA proposal. Thus, it is apparent from that provision that project promoters are required to submit an investment request to the competent national authorities of the Member States concerned so that the allocation of costs can be properly assessed. Under Article 12(4) of the 2013 TEN-E Regulation, NRAs must take, within six months of receipt of the request, ‘coordinated decisions on the allocation of investment costs to be borne by each system operator for the project, as well as their inclusion in tariffs’.

71 It follows from all those provisions that, with the exception of certain situations which are not relevant in the present case, such as the situation where the investment costs are borne entirely by the TSOs concerned or by the project promoters, project promoters must submit an investment request to all the NRAs concerned. Therefore, CINEA correctly considered that, in order to meet the requirements of Article 12 of the 2013 TEN-E Regulation, the CBCA decision should have been based on an investment request addressed to the NRAs of the Member States concerned.

72 In the present case, it should be noted that, on 18 May 2023, the applicant did in fact submit to the network regulators of Cyprus, Greece and Italy a document entitled ‘Investment Request’. However, as CINEA states in its written pleadings, it is apparent from that document that the applicant intends to apply for EU grants and that it needs a CBCA decision from the NRAs in order to be able to submit its proposal to CINEA. However, that document does not contain a request for a financial contribution to the project from the Member States concerned. Thus, CINEA was fully entitled to find that, while formally designated as an ‘investment request’, that document, having regard to its content, cannot be classified as a genuine investment request. In any event, it should be noted that, at the hearing, the applicant itself acknowledged that it did not request any financial contribution from the Member States concerned.

73 In the absence of an investment request validly submitted by the applicant, the NRAs were not able to examine, in their decision, the possibility of cost recovery through regulatory tariffs, in accordance with the requirements of Article 12(1), (3) and (4) of the 2013 TEN-E Regulation, read in the light of recital 42 of that regulation. Consequently, the proposal at issue did not allow CINEA to verify that a regulatory solution had actually been explored before applying for EU financial assistance and that that solution was considered not sufficient to deliver the necessary investments. Thus, CINEA was correct in finding that the NRA decision submitted by the applicant did not comply with Article 12 of the 2013 TEN-E Regulation and that, consequently, the proposal at issue was incomplete.

74 As regards the applicant’s argument that recital 42 of the 2013 TEN-E Regulation has no binding legal force, it must be borne in mind that even though the preamble to an EU act has no binding legal force and cannot be relied on as a ground either for derogating from the actual provisions of the act in question or for interpreting those provisions in a manner that is clearly contrary to their wording, it may explain their content, since the recitals in that preamble constitute important elements for the purposes of interpretation that may clarify the intentions of the author of that act (see judgment of 26 January 2021, Hessischer Rundfunk , C‑422/19 and C‑423/19, EU:C:2021:63, paragraph 64 and the case-law cited).

75 That is the case here, since recital 42 of the 2013 TEN-E Regulation clarifies the nature of the requirements laid down in Article 12 of that regulation.

76 Therefore, the applicant’s arguments concerning the first ground of the contested decision, based on the absence of an investment request, are unfounded.

77 In that regard, it should be noted that the failure to comply with the requirement to submit an investment request pursuant to Article 12(3) of the 2013 TEN-E Regulation constitutes an autonomous and sufficient ground in itself for a finding that the document in question does not comply with Article 12 of the 2013 TEN-E Regulation. It is apparent from Article 12(1), (3) and (4) of the 2013 TEN-E Regulation, read in the light of recital 42 of that regulation, that an investment request is an essential element for an NRA decision to be compliant with the applicable regulatory requirements. Thus, even if one of the three other grounds relied on by CINEA in the contested decision, namely the failure to comply with the principle of EU grants as a last resort, the lack of clarity as regards the tariff regulation of the project and the lack of details on the advantages for Cyprus, were to contain an error, that would not affect the legality of that decision, which has a sufficient basis in law on the first ground.

78 Consequently, the rejection of the applicant’s arguments directed against the first ground leads to the rejection of the present plea, without there being any need to examine the other complaints raised by the applicant against the three other grounds of non-compliance set out in the contested decision.

79 Accordingly, the second plea must be rejected.

Third plea in law, alleging breach of the right to be heard

80 The applicant alleges infringement of Article 41 of the Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union (‘the Charter’), resulting from a breach of the principle of good administration and from its right to be heard. It maintains that it should have been consulted during the examination of the admissibility of its proposal, before the adoption of the contested decision. Such a consultation would have led CINEA to adopt a different decision on the proposal at issue.

81 CINEA disputes the applicant’s arguments.

82 In that regard, it must be borne in mind that, under Article 41(2) of the Charter, the right to good administration includes the right of every person to be heard before any individual measure which would affect him or her adversely is taken.

83 As is apparent from its very wording, Article 41(2) of the Charter is of general application. Accordingly, the right to be heard must be observed in all proceedings which are liable to culminate in a measure adversely affecting a person, even where the applicable legislation does not expressly provide for such a procedural requirement (see judgment of 18 June 2020, Commission v RQ , C‑831/18 P, EU:C:2020:481, paragraph 67 and the case-law cited).

84 That right extends to all the factual and legal material which forms the basis of the decision-making act, but not to the final position which the authority intends to adopt (see judgment of 14 July 2021, Interpipe Niko Tube and Interpipe Nizhnedneprovsky Tube Rolling Plant v Commission , T‑716/19, EU:T:2021:457, paragraph 211 and the case-law cited).

85 Lastly, the existence of an irregularity in the observance of the right to be heard can lead to the annulment of the contested act only to the extent that there is a possibility that, if there had been no irregularity, the administrative procedure might have led to a different result, thereby materially affecting the rights of defence of the party concerned. However, that party cannot be required to demonstrate that the contested decision would have been different, but simply that such a possibility cannot be totally ruled out, since that party would have been better able to defend itself if there had been no procedural irregularity (see, to that effect, judgment of 14 July 2021, Interpipe Niko Tube and Interpipe Nizhnedneprovsky Tube Rolling Plant v Commission , T‑716/19, EU:T:2021:457, paragraph 210 and the case-law cited).

86 By contrast, it is for the party concerned to establish specifically how it would have been better able to ensure its defence in the absence of that procedural irregularity, without merely pleading that it was impossible for it to provide comments on hypothetical situations (see judgment of 10 April 2019, Jindal Saw and Jindal Saw Italia v Commission , T‑300/16, EU:T:2019:235, paragraph 79 and the case-law cited).

87 In the present case, it must be borne in mind that CINEA rejected the proposal at issue at the stage of examining admissibility. The applicant, claiming a breach of its right to be heard, complains that it was not consulted before the adoption of the contested decision.

88 It is apparent from the case-law that, in award procedures, the right to be heard is guaranteed at the time when the tender or proposal is submitted, and by the possibility for the tenderer or candidate to request clarification. Therefore, the fact that no subsequent stage is envisaged in which to provide supplementary explanations, after the proposals or tenders have been evaluated, cannot amount to an infringement of Article 41(2)(a) of the Charter (see, by analogy, judgment of 19 November 2025, LGAI Technological Center and jtsec Beyond IT Security v EUSPA , T‑41/24, not published, EU:T:2025:1042, paragraph 37).

89 In addition, the right to be heard may also be ensured by the possibility for the contracting authority to contact the applicant, on the basis of Article 200(3) of Regulation (EU, Euratom) 2018/1046 of the European Parliament and of the Council of 18 July 2018 on the financial rules applicable to the general budget of the Union, amending Regulations (EU) No 1296/2013, (EU) No 1301/2013, (EU) No 1303/2013, (EU) No 1304/2013, (EU) No 1309/2013, (EU) No 1316/2013, (EU) No 223/2014, (EU) No 283/2014, and Decision No 541/2014/EU and repealing Regulation (EU, Euratom) No 966/2012 (OJ 2018 L 193, p. 1; ‘the 2018 Financial Regulation’), to obtain missing information or clarifications.

90 In that regard, Article 200(2) and (7) of the 2018 Financial Regulation, which concerns the evaluation procedure for proposals, provides that applicants whose proposals are rejected at any stage are to be informed, giving them the reasons for the rejection of the application.

91 Thus, it must be held that CINEA is not required to hear applicants at the stage of verifying the admissibility of their funding proposals, or to provide them with additional explanations before the adoption of a rejection decision, but that it must inform them of that decision, giving them the reasons for the rejection of the application.

92 Moreover, as stated in the letter informing the applicant of the contested decision, the applicant had two administrative channels available to it for reviewing the legality of that decision, which would have enabled it to exercise its right to be heard at the pre-litigation stage, by submitting a request for evaluation review or a request for review of legality under Article 22 of Council Regulation (EC) No 58/2003 of 19 December 2002 laying down the statute for executive agencies to be entrusted with certain tasks in the management of Community programmes (OJ 2003 L 11, p. 1). However, having decided not to make use of those administrative procedures, the applicant cannot criticise CINEA for the absence of a subsequent stage for the provision of supplementary explanations.

93 Furthermore, it should be noted that, even though no specific provision specifically provides for the applicant to be consulted during the award procedure, CINEA and the Commission, in order to explain the rules for preparing a CBCA decision and to provide the necessary information, organised prior consultations with project promoters and NRAs on 15 December 2023 and 8 April 2024, that is to say, prior to the contested decision. Therefore, the applicant’s claim that no consultation was organised before the contested decision was adopted is unfounded.

94 Lastly, and in any event, even if an irregularity had been committed, the applicant has in no way shown that the contested decision might have been different if it had been heard on the grounds for rejecting its proposal before the adoption of the contested decision. The applicant merely claims that, if CINEA had given it the opportunity to do so, it would have explained that all the documents submitted to CINEA complied with the requirements of the call for proposals, without, however, putting forward any specific arguments in that regard.

95 The third plea in law must therefore be rejected and, accordingly, the application for annulment must be dismissed in its entirety.

The claim for damages

96 The applicant seeks, in essence, compensation for the damage consisting of the loss of an opportunity to be granted funds following a full evaluation and award procedure. The damage allegedly suffered follows directly from the contested decision.

97 As a preliminary point, it should be recalled that, pursuant to the second paragraph of Article 340 TFEU, in the case of non-contractual liability, the Union, in accordance with the general principles common to the laws of the Member States, is to make good any damage caused by its institutions or by its servants in the performance of their duties.

98 According to well-established case-law, in order for the European Union to incur non-contractual liability under the second paragraph of Article 340 TFEU for unlawful conduct on the part of its institutions, a set of conditions must be fulfilled, namely the illegality of the allegedly wrongful conduct of the institutions, actual harm and the existence of a causal link between the conduct and the harm alleged to have been suffered. Where one of those conditions is not satisfied the application must be dismissed in its entirety, without there being any need to examine the other conditions (see judgment of 15 October 2013, Evropaïki Dynamiki v Commission , T‑474/10, not published, EU:T:2013:528, paragraph 215 and the case-law cited; see also, to that effect, judgment of 9 September 2008, FIAMM and Others v Council and Commission , C‑120/06 P and C‑121/06 P, EU:C:2008:476, paragraphs 106 and 164 to 166 and the case-law cited).

99 In addition, it should be borne in mind that, according to case-law, the action in support of which damage resulting from loss of profit is claimed must be dismissed, because the damage at issue is not real and existing, but future and hypothetical (see order of 8 December 2011, Evropaïki Dynamiki v Commission , T‑39/08, not published, EU:T:2011:721, paragraph 47 and the case-law cited).

100 In the present case, as is apparent from the considerations pertaining to the claims for annulment, no unlawful conduct is disclosed by the examination of the applicant’s pleas and arguments. It follows that the requirement that the conduct of which CINEA is accused must be unlawful is not satisfied.

101 Since one of the three conditions for the European Union to incur non-contractual liability is not satisfied, the European Union cannot be held liable. The claim for damages must therefore be rejected, without there being any need to examine whether the other two conditions are satisfied.

102 It follows from the foregoing that the claim for damages must be rejected as unfounded and the action in its entirety must be dismissed.

Costs

103 Under Article 134(1) of the Rules of Procedure of the General Court, the unsuccessful party is to be ordered to pay the costs if they have been applied for in the successful party’s pleadings.

104 Since the applicant has been unsuccessful, it must be ordered to bear its own costs and to pay those incurred by CINEA, in accordance with the form of order sought by CINEA.

On those grounds,

THE GENERAL COURT (Tenth Chamber)

hereby:

1. Dismisses the action;

2. Orders Ypothalassios Agogos Fysikou Aeriou Elladas – Italias – Poseidon AE (YAFA Poseidon) to pay the costs.

KalėdaKanninenPerišin

Delivered in open court in Luxembourg on 4 November 2026.

T. HenzeM.J. Costeira
Acting RegistrarPresident

* Language of the case: English.